Lineout Calls of the Week

Well, we think it’s only fair to say that the primary focus of this week’s edition is Women’s Rugby. There was that thrilling conclusion to the Women’s Six Nations last weekend, which saw England become Grand Slam Champions for the third year in a row and the 16th time since the tournament began in 1996. Whichever way you cut it, that is an extremely impressive record, and one that on their present form shows no sign of being broken any time soon, despite a very determined France’s best efforts. There were some terrific matches this tournament and despite playing probably the worst game of the Championship when they played England and were put to the sword by the Red Roses, Ireland went from last year’s Wooden Spoon holders to finishing third and with it both automatic qualification for next year’s World Cup as well as the Tier 1 WXV competition at the end of this year. It was a much needed boost for Women’s Rugby in Ireland, which had plummeted from being Six Nations and Grand Slam Champions in 2013 to failing to qualify for the last World Cup.

To cap off a memorable weekend in Women’s Rugby our own fantastic Canadian Women got their Pacific Four campaign off to a rousing start in California by completely demolishing a US side that simply had no answers for their clinical and brutally efficient second half performance. It was only Canada’s first game of the year, and there were clearly some cobwebs to be dusted off in the first half, but the fourth best team in the world are already looking exceptionally dangerous.

In the rest of the rugby world, there was plenty of action as both Super Rugby Pacific and the URC, along with France’s Top 14 and the English Premiership all approach the business end of their seasons and those all important playoff spots. As we sadly don’t really follow events in France and England as these are purely domestic competitions, we can’t really comment but from snippets we have seen there have been some thrilling encounters and this upcoming weekend’s Champions Cup semi final between Toulouse and Harlequins looks set to be a cracker.

In Super Rugby Pacific, a familiar pattern seems to be once more emerging that Australian sides are unlikely to go much further than the Quarter Finals, and there are only two sides for whom that looks set to be a certainty. The United Rugby Championship also is increasingly looking skewed in favor of Ireland and South Africa, making that two Test series between the two in July a mouth watering prospect. However, Scottish interests are well represented by Glasgow, and Italy remains ever hopeful courtesy of an impressive looking Benetton outfit. In short, everything to play for now in these final few weeks of regular season competition in both hemispheres.

England reign supreme yet again, and who can stop them heading into a World Cup in their own backyard?

At next year’s World Cup in England, it will take an extraordinary team to derail the phenomenal prowess of the Red Roses

England may not be defending Champions when next year’s World Cup kicks off in their backyard, but it’s already proving difficult to see them as anything less by the time it all wraps up. Agreed, it’s New Zealand who are the current World Champions, but at last year’s WXV Tier 1 competition, they lost to England in Auckland. With England’s clinical demolition of France in Bordeaux last weekend, they have now beaten the French consistently for the last three years. In short, there is England, and seemingly, there is everyone else. New Zealand, France and Canada are all exceptional teams in their own right, and there is little doubt that by the time the World Cup rolls around they will have the potential to rain on England’s home parade, but it is going to take every ounce of ingenuity, composure and commitment with a generous dose of good luck thrown in for good measure.

England continued to trade on their physical dominance this Six Nations, and we have yet to see a team that can compete with them in that regard. However, England have now developed an attacking game that, at times, left us, let alone their opponents, breathless this Six Nations. Head Coach John Mitchell has added an offensive edge to this team to complement their physical game. Holly Aitchison at fly half has been the epitome of a quick thinking but strategic playmaker at fly half. Although the final game was more a showcase of England’s ability to cross the whitewash with their formidable forward pack, other games showed off the dazzling footwork and strength in the tackle of England’s assets out wide in the shape of Abby Dow and Jess Breach. One of the revelations of the tournament, particularly against Ireland was fullback Ellie Kildunne who was nothing short of sensational and ended up being the tournament’s leading try scorer.

While this tournament was a showcase of England’s player skills, as a team and as individuals, they simply dominated the vast majority of statistics across the board. Their opponents consistently struggled to stamp their own authority on any of the games in which England featured. It was only France who, in a second half, played at breakneck speed, looked like they had earned the right to play their own game and possibly get the better of England. In short, there is very little to say other than congratulations to a team who were simply the best at everything they did.

As they look ahead to the WXV Tier 1 Competition this year in Canada in September/October they know they have some work to do but it’s simply a case of fine tuning rather than wholesale fixes. Despite their phenomenal physical prowess, their scrum surprisingly remains a liability on occasion, and they had one of the lowest success rates in the tournament, with only Wales and Ireland faring worse than they did in terms of success at scrum time. Their goal kicking could do with some improvement, but then when you score as many tries as England did, it’s not surprising they missed the odd conversion. Nevertheless, come the World Cup next year, they won’t want to be missing valuable points opportunities in close games.

Apart from that, however, England can reflect on a memorable tournament that has clearly cemented their reputation as the current Rolls Royce standard of Women’s Rugby!

Ireland’s Women cautiously crawl out of the abyss they’d fallen into for the last four years

It’s been a long time coming, but Ireland are clearly starting to enjoy themselves again, even if that game against England is still a mighty large elephant in the room

The neglect of the Women’s game in Ireland over the last few years has been an injustice, particularly when juxtaposed against the remarkable success of the Men’s game. There is still a long way to go, but this Six Nations finally saw Ireland start to rediscover some of the magic that saw them win the tournament in 2013 and 2015, with the 2013 win achieved on the back of a Grand Slam. You got the feeling that a corner had finally been turned in their opener against France when they denied the French the opportunity to relax for the full eighty minutes in Le Mans. They could and should have beaten Italy at home a week later had it not been for some questionable decision-making at times. That got rectified two weeks later as they put in a solid and composed performance against Wales and got themselves a handsome win in the process.

The game against Wales made the outright disaster at Twickenham a week later, all the more difficult to both understand and justify. The 88-10 drubbing at the hands of England was painful to watch, and Ireland were woeful plain and simple. Very few people expected them to win, but to capitulate in the manner they did was hard to fathom. As England essentially scored a try every six minutes, Ireland looked at sixes and sevens defensively for the full eighty minutes. Once again, the questionable decision making that tripped them up against Italy came to the fore, and we lost track of the number of handling errors. In short, it’s one thing to lose against arguably the best team in the world, but to not show up for the occasion is another matter altogether, and at times Ireland were guilty of doing just that.

The final game against Scotland wasn’t pretty at times, but Ireland regained their shape and the composure that made them so effective against Wales. Their lineout remains a red flag item heading into both the WXV Tier 1 at the end of this year and, more importantly, the World Cup in 2025, which they have now qualified for. Their goal kicking could use some work, and their scrum definitely creaks at times. However, they are becoming as ferocious and effective in the rucks and at the breakdown as their male colleagues are renowned for, and they passed the ball more than any other team this Six Nations. If they can just make said passes go to hand then in winger Beibhinn Parsons they have a player who was second in the tournament to England’s phenomenal Ellie Kildunne for metres gained and metres carried, while in flanker Aoife Wafer they have one of the most exciting new players in the Northern Hemisphere.

Ireland are back and although they may have tripped over their bootlaces a few too many times this tournament there is no denying that this is a side who mean to make a statement once more in the years to come. In short, watch this space.

Canada make a statement that they clearly intend to pick up where they left off last year by putting the USA to the sword in the opening Round of the Pacific Four series

Canada set out their stall for 2024 with an emphatic win over the USA in Round 1 of the Pacific Four Series, in which Captain Sophie de Goede showcased once more why she is likely to end up as one of the greatest players of her generation

First, let’s give Captain Sophie de Goede and every one of her exceptional charges a standing ovation for that performance last Sunday against the USA. Given the disastrous state of the Men’s game in this country, De Goede and her colleagues gave us an 80-minute display that made us feel almost deliriously proud to be Canadian rugby fans. This really is a remarkable team for whom the future looks exceptionally bright indeed.

It was obvious that there were a few cobwebs to be dusted off in the first quarter, but Canada still found themselves 10-0 after only 10 minutes. The USA did manage to find their feet and fought their way back into the game, ending the first half 17-7 behind, but in the second half, Canada simply tore away in a clinical and perfectly executed game. Canada were on point, and their kicking game was outstanding. Once they found their groove, they were away, and there was simply no looking back as Canada ran away comfortable 50-7 winners. The only criticism we could make was stated in no uncertain terms by Captain Sophie de Goede in the post-match interview. They simply need to play with the same intensity and precision in the first half of games that they showed in that second half against the USA. If they do, then arguably, the sky is the limit for this team.

With the core of the team now seasoned professionals in Europe, there is experience and big match temperament in this Canadian squad. Well Coached by Kevin Rouet, we were impressed by how well drilled they looked after only 30 minutes considering this was their first game together since that memorable win against France last November in the WXV Tier 1 competition, which saw Canada finish second. Sophie de Goede is the glue that holds this exceptional team together, but veterans such as prop Emily Tutosi, second rower Tyson Beukeboom, scrum half Justine Pelletier and centre Alex Tessier provide the spine of a team that clearly gels both on and off the pitch. Add to that some genuinely exciting new talent in the shape of back rowers Pamphinette Buisa and Julia Omokhuale, fly half Claire Gallagher and utility back Fancy Bermudez Chavez, and Canada looks well positioned to be one of the contenders come the World Cup next year.

There are plenty of stern challenges ahead in the next few months which will really allow Canada’s remarkable women to measure where they are at in relation to the likes of England, New Zealand and France – but we think all the signs are already looking exceptionally positive. Roll on May 10th, which sees their next Pacific Four fixture against 5th ranked Australia and onwards and upwards ladies!!!

Is it business as usual once again in Super Rugby Pacific as we edge towards the playoffs?

New Zealand’s Hurricanes look to be the side to beat, but their loss to Australia’s Brumbies last weekend proved that they are not invincible. However, it’s still hard to see a semi-final lineup that doesn’t as always comprise three New Zealand teams and one solitary Australian side in the shape of the Brumbies.

Super Rugby Pacific is the big conundrum here at the Lineout. We’ll be completely honest and say that individual loyalties aside, the competition still fails to fire our imagination. That is not to say for a moment that there isn’t some outstanding rugby on display – far from it. Watch the highlights reel of any weekend, and there is more action and try scoring glory than most tournaments serve up in a month. However, as a competition, its outcome still seems to be all too inevitable. Come the semi-finals it will essentially become a New Zealand domestic competition, with the possibility of one Australian side, most likely the Brumbies, thrown into the mix to give it a semblance of being the Southern Hemisphere’s showpiece club/franchise tournament. Given the woeful state of Australian rugby at the moment, even that mix could be doubtful.

Let’s look at the front runners so far, for those four semi-final berths – you guessed it the Hurricanes, Blues and Chiefs from New Zealand and the Brumbies from Australia. The defending champions New Zealand’s Crusaders are making a late charge and could well end up bagging a quarter final spot, but in reality they are a shadow of the side that has so completely dominated the competition for the last seven consecutive years. New Zealand’s other outfit the Highlanders have simply not been at the races in Super Rugby Pacific since its Post Covid inception in 2022, to the point where they are consistently duking it out at the bottom of the table with the likes of the Western Force and Moana Pasifika. The Hurricanes given that they have only lost one game this season on the road to the Brumbies are likely to head into the playoffs at the top of the log, with a relatively easy ride to the end of their season, if their form holds. For the second placed Blues, it’s a slightly less comfortable ride, but if anything, their form seems to be improving as the season draws to a close. Finally fourth placed Chiefs have arguably the hardest road to the knockouts but with extraordinary fly half Damian McKenzie allied to new sensation Cortez Ratima in the other halfback slot and a back line that can slice and dice opposition defenses at will they should get the job done relatively easily.

In Australia, as they do every year, the Brumbies still look the most complete side on the western side of the Tasman and expect to see new Wallaby Coach Joe Scmidt draw a significant number of his squad from the Canberra outfit. They may not be the flashiest unit on the Australian circuit, but they know better than any other Australian squad how to work as a team and get the job done, and most importantly, secure those all important results. However, their two losses to date this year both on the road and to New Zealand sides, make for uncomfortable viewing as while they will most likely secure a home quarter final, thereafter some form of life on the road beckons. Surprisingly it’s the Melbourne Rebels, despite their financial woes, who are the next best Australian outift, but like the Queensland Reds right behind them in sixth place, consistency is not their strong suit and in the Rebels case they have yet to trouble a New Zealand side except for the utterly woeful Highlanders. For the Reds, there is no denying they are an exciting team to watch and in the shape of new winger Tim Ryan they have probably discovered the most exciting thing to happen to Australian attacking rugby since David Campese and Michael Lynagh. However, their run to the playoffs is an uncomfortable ride, featuring a trip to Fortress Fiji, and then the home of a rejuvenated Crusaders side in New Zealand. For the Rebels it’s an even more challenging road trip seeing them pack their bags to Fiji, Brisbane and Canberra, with their only two home games being against the red hot Blues and Chiefs from across the Tasman. As for the Waratahs and Western Force, pride is sadly the only thing left at stake for the remainder of the season.

Of the two Pacific Island sides, Fijian Drua are the strongest team, and the chances of them making a quarter final are looking like a very safe bet. However, they haven’t looked all that flash on the road, and New Zealand’s Hurricanes managed to break their winning streak at home with a win in Suva, though nobody seems to be able to crack Fortress Lautoka. They do have a relatively favorable fixture list in the runup to the playoffs with two home games against the Reds and Rebels. Then it’s a potentially easy road trip to Dunedin to face New Zealand’s bottom feeders the Highlanders along with a trip to Perth to face Australia’s worst outfit the Western Force. However, no one will envy them this weekend’s trip to Canberra to take on the Brumbies. Defensively, they also haven’t been that sharp, and discipline continues to trip them up in the heat of the moment. They have been huge entertainment value as always, especially at home in the Islands, but in all reality, a quarter-final berth is where the party is likely to end.

As for the other Pacific Island side, if you can really call them that considering they play 90% of their games at their “home” stadium of Mount Smart in New Zealand, Moana Pasifika have been fun to watch but have never really looked like upsetting any kind of established pecking order. A lot of their set piece work with the exception of their scrum is weak, and defensively, they often look suspect. A feisty and courageous team sadly lacking composure under pressure and the execution needed at times to win consistently. However, their game this weekend against the Highlanders in Tonga will be a great celebration of Pacific Island rugby, and we have a hunch Moana will make the locals proud.

We really hope that the end of this Super Rugby Pacific regular season will turn the competition on its head and make for a set of playoffs that turn the traditional form book inside out, but somehow it’s already shaping up to be yet another case of dusting off the turntable and playing that New Zealand’s greatest hits album all over again.

Glasgow and Munster show Leinster the error of traveling to South Africa late in the season with an understrength squad while the Bulls show why they’ve put all their eggs in the URC basket this year

Glasgow are running with all their big guns in the runoff to the playoffs, which allowed them to pip Leinster to the top of the table this weekend. Meanwhile Munster show that life on the road at the end of the season is a chore to be relished and embraced and which seems to bring out the best in them, while the Bulls have clearly made the URC the focus of their attention this year

What error we hear you say in relation to Leinster. They have to focus on their Champions Cup home semi final at a sold out Croke Park this weekend against Northampton, so it was no wonder they kept the big guns at home for the two week trip to South Africa, just like the Bulls chose to keep their hotshots at home instead of putting up a legitimate challenge in the Champions Cup so they could focus on the URC. So far it seems to be paying dividends for both teams, and Leinster are still second on the URC log with three relatively soft matches left in the URC and as a result plenty of time to wrestle back that top spot on the log from Glasgow. It’s very hard to argue with that logic, and in Leinster’s case given their stellar form both in Europe and the URC it’s not difficult to see them in the driving seat once more when the URC regular season wraps up on May 31st.

However, there is no denying that the focus has shifted to Scotland and Glasgow after their demolition of a hapless Zebre Parma last weekend catapulted them to the top of the URC log. With them out of the Champions Cup you can rest assured that they will be taking their two week tour of South Africa which will see them face both the Lions and the Bulls on the Highveld, very seriously indeed, with a contingent of front line troops on the long flight South. Come out of that with flying colors and a soft home game against Zebre Parma could see the Scottish side emerge top of the table at the end of the regular season. We can’t wait to find out!

And then there’s Ireland’s third placed Munster, who, just like last year, all of a sudden look like genuine contenders at the end of the regular season and seem to relish a late tour to South Africa. Unlike Leinster, they traveled to South Africa with all their heavies and got back to back results on the highveld against the Bulls and the Lions. They like Glasgow have a relatively straightforward end of season with two local derbies at the hallowed and often impregnable ground of Thomond Park against Connacht and Ulster and what should be an uncomplicated trip to Edinburgh given their excellent away form.

For South Africa’s Bulls, who currently sit in fourth it’s still a tough slog to the knockout stages even if they have the luxury of facing a potentially jet lagged but table topping Glasgow at Fortress Loftus Versfeld. That’s followed by a visit from Italy’s red hot Benetton, though the Italians will not have had the luxury of a week to acclimatize to the vagaries of playing at altitude coming straight from the steamy lowlands of Durban and the Shark Tank. Deal with the Scots and the Italians and the Bulls should be in the playoffs but they still face a challenging final regular season game on the road against a dramatically improved Sharks outfit.

Those are the teams we think will be in the semis, but what of the rest and the Quarters we hear you ask? We can’t see much change out of the Stormers, Connacht, Ulster, and Benetton making up the other four spots in the last eight going to the Quarters. Of those four and despite a strong campaign to date Benetton have the toughest end to their season, comprising two away games in South Africa, with the added complexity in addition to the travel of one being at sea level and the other at altitude. There’s an outside chance, and we mean outside that the Sharks could blaze their way off the back of three maximum points haul wins to that last Quarter Final spot, but we have trouble believing it.

The three main three wild cards are the Lions, Edinburgh, and Ospreys. For the Lions, their final two fixtures are a bit daunting, to say the least, admittedly a home fixture against Glasgow, but that’s followed by a trip to Cape Town and the Stormers. The Ospreys do have one soft target in terms of a home fixture against struggling Welsh compatriots the Dragons and then away to Cardiff, but their next immediate fixture against Leinster on the road is likely to be a foregone conclusion and one not in their favor. Last but not least, Edinburgh will be hoping that Ulster’s tough end to the season may help slingshot them into the final eight, providing they can make sense of Benetton in their final game on the road.

There’s no denying that the URC is arguably becoming the most fascinating of all the regular club competitions outside the Champions Cup, given the variety of playing cultures it embraces. It’s a much flashier product than the old rather stodgy and lackluster Pro14, which a bit like Super Rugby Pacific was for the most part dominated by Irish teams come the business end of things and lost much of its international appeal. Sure some of the logistics leave a bit to be desired at times, particularly juxtaposed against the demands of International Rugby and the European Champions Cup, but it’s still become a competition that we thoroughly enjoy, and it’s conclusion this year looks set to be even more fascinating than last year’s thrills and spills.

Well, that’s it for this missive. There’s lots to look forward to in the coming month, so strap yourselves in. The conclusion of the Champions Cup and the wrapping up of the regular seasons in Super Rugby and the URC are all in the mix, and perhaps best of all for us here in Canada, our extraordinary Women in action in the Pacific Four Series. Enjoy it all along with the start of spring and time to haul out the barbecues and enjoy some deck life once more!

The Lineout Calls of the Week

Where to begin since we last put pen to paper? The Six Nations is over for another year, but this year’s edition is one that will definitely remain on our playlists for many years to come. Ireland emerged as the deserved Champions in the end without a Grand Slam and were pushed hard at the end by both England and Scotland. A great side yes, but definitely not the best side in the world despite what their media may think, with the forthcoming two match series to South Africa in the summer, the real test as to whether or not that epithet is deserved or not. France after a truly horrific start, managed to snap out of their World Cup malaise in the final two rounds and finally began to show us that once the blue machine clicks into gear it’s hard to beat. England’s defeat of Ireland in Round 4 was the crowning achievement of a tournament that saw them build on their World Cup successes in leaps and bounds and finally look like a side that everyone needs to be wary of – take note New Zealand come the summer! Scotland impressed when needed to but retained their Championship defining status of being consistently inconsistent and as a result despite all the promise never really being title contenders – cue broken record of the last twenty years. Italy blew us all, including Wales and Scotland, off the park this year, and although we say it quietly would finally have appeared to have earned the right to dream big dreams. Last but definitely not least, although Wales were left clutching the Wooden Spoon and lost all their games, we can’t help feeling that all the gloom and doom in the Principality is rather misplaced.

Talking of the Six Nations, though, we’re delighted that it’s not over yet. Yes, the Women’s version is in full swing, and we, for one, are excited by what we’re seeing. First up, the quality of rugby on display appears to have gone up yet another notch from last year’s excellent tournament. Ireland and Scotland seem to be quietly getting their houses in order and look set to have a much better tournament this year than last year’s poor showings. Wales, despite losing their opening game, are never to be taken lightly, and we have a hunch they will only get better as the tournament progresses despite the calamitous predicament that the sport finds itself in in the Principality. France, just as they did last year, are just warming up to the task at hand now that the initial cobwebs have been dusted off. Italy will also only get better as they managed to hold England scoreless until the 30th minute in their opener, after which the wheels admittedly did fall off rather dramatically, but then it is against England we’re talking about. However, just like last year, England look disturbingly ominous already at this early stage, though not quite the juggernaut they appeared to be last year. In short, it looks set to be a thrilling tournament, but perhaps what was most heartening for us was to see the packed stands for all three matches, particularly in Cardiff and Le Mans, which once again serves to highlight the growth and appeal of the Women’s’ game. With the Pacific Four just around the corner for our fabulous Canadian Women and then the WXV, what a fantastic year lies ahead of the 2025 World Cup for Women’s Rugby.

Last but not least, Super Rugby is starting to get genuinely interesting. The question remarks remain about Australian rugby, but the Reds and Brumbies so far seem to be making a strong statement that all is not lost in a Land Down Under. However, it’s still early days yet and these two sides always tend to look strong at the start and then fade as the playoffs loom, making the next month’s round of action a critical time under the microscope for Australian rugby, as there is plenty of Trans Tasman action on offer to see how well these sides can face up to international competition. However, the big talking point for us here is just how much fun Fijian Drua’s season is turning out to be. We always suspected it would be, especially with so many games being played in front of their delirious home fans. Fortress Fiji is rapidly turning into a very daunting place to travel to, and if the enthusiasm of the fans in the stands doesn’t ooze off your TV screens into your living rooms then we’d argue you’re more a casual spectator than a genuine rugby fan. The Drua are building towards a favorable run to the playoffs, and if they can capitalise on their momentum so far, we’re in for some SERIOUS entertainment. Let the games begin. We’re already practicing the “Na Bole” – so step aside all Haka lovers.

So that’s what got us talking this week, and without further ado, let’s get into it!

Ireland look at lot better than the Wooden Spoon holders they were last year, while Scotland look to escape the bottom half of the table this year

Both Ireland and Scotland look like this year could give them genuine reasons for optimism after last year saw them have less than uplifting campaigns

This year’s Women’s Six Nations looks set to be even better than last year’s edition and a tad more competitive. Admittedly, England, in particular, look the front runners, but France are rapidly warming to the task and ultimately look to be challenging the Red Roses’ dominance. However, what is perhaps most exciting is that Scotland look to be making a strong mid table challenge, while Ireland who were seriously adrift last year also look like they may be able to hand the Wooden Spoon they collected in 2023 to someone else. Italy, meanwhile remain the exciting package they always are despite a very wobbly start against England. Last but not least, Wales should not be written off despite sitting firmly on the bottom rung of the ladder after the first two rounds. However, perhaps the most heartening thing has been the packed stands and crowd enthusiasm which once again reinforces not only the quality of rugby being played but the continued growth of and support for the Women’s game which is fantastic to see.

England, however, will take some beating whichever way you look at it. They dominate most of the statistics but don’t quite look as polished as they did last year. The opening game against Italy required a lot of cobwebs to be blown off, and for the first 30 minutes, England did not look at the races and made an uncharacteristically high number of errors. However, thereafter, it appeared relatively plain sailing. In their next match against Wales they looked considerably sharper, but how sharp remains questionable as sadly Wales were poor whichever way you cut it. Their next fixture in a fortnight’s time against Scotland in Edinburgh will tell us a great deal about where England are headed by the time they face their most likely challenger for the silverware France at the end of the tournament. Their goal kicking as evidenced in the game against Wales could do with some serious improvement, but otherwise, this is a very polished looking unit indeed.

France, look set for a strong finish but were pushed hard by both Ireland and Scotland. Scotland pushed them to the limits for the full eighty in Edinburgh, and Ireland put up a feisty challenge in Le Mans at times in their opening match. Nevertheless, France, as they always do in this tournament, get better with each outing. They face an intriguing fixture with a fired up Italy in a fortnight’s time in Paris, but much like England it’s hard to find any glaring faults with this French team and their set piece work is arguably the best in the competition. They also have the advantage of their toughest game being their last against the Red Roses, and in France’s southwest, the country’s spiritual home of rugby to boot. France are just getting going, and everyone else has now been warned.

Italy continue to be the dark horse of the Women’s Six Nations. Despite their blowout against England, in the first round, this is a very dangerous and capable team. With the confidence of a solid win over a vastly improved Irish side in Dublin last weekend, they will be feeling confident about their date with France in Paris as their next fixture. Their defense in their own 22 against a determined Irish outfit was impressive, and they’ll need it against a French side adept at exposing defensive frailties close to the try line. However as strong as they are defensively in their own 22 their tackle success rate elsewhere across the pitch is the poorest in the competition and will need to dramatically improve if they are to handle France’s silky runners.

Scotland, this year, it has to be said, do look impressive. It was a gritty display against Wales in their opener, and if they keep it up then a much cherished spot in the WXV Tier One competition against the World’s best at the end of the year is a distinct possibility. They found the going tough against Wales on the road in their opener but found a way to hang on and claim a valuable win, while against France last weekend, they managed to remain within three points of their opponents for almost the full eighty minutes while denying the French access to the try line despite Les Bleus having the lion’s share of territory and being the more dominant side in attack. Their defense has been superb, and their tackle rate is one of the highest and most successful in the competition so far. Consequently, they must be feeling more than a little optimistic about the tall order of hosting England in just under two weeks.

Ireland, for us, have so far been a revelation. They were poor last year, but the Irish team that has shown up in the first two rounds of this year’s competition has looked hugely improved from last year’s Wooden Spoon edition. It is still clearly a work in progress, and they remain winless after the first two rounds, but we think there could well be two wins up for grabs this year. First up is the chance to host a struggling Welsh outfit in Dublin in two weeks. If that goes well and they are able to provide England as much competition as they did France, then their final game in Dublin against a tricky Scottish outfit, could end up being a positive step in their rebuilding programme. All this is not to say that they aren’t without their problems. Their set piece work remains poor with a faltering lineout and scrum, and their decision-making at times against Italy was lamentable allied to some poor execution under pressure. However, they look a lot more focused than last year, and their attacking game at times is ferocious as is their overall commitment, all of which is a far cry from what we saw 12 months ago. The skills are there they just need to be fine-tuned, and we imagine they will have been by the time the tournament wraps up next month, giving them a strong start to their rebuilding process.

As for Wales, we’re just not sure what’s not working as they looked so promising last year, but it’s clearly not clicking for them this time around. Their set piece work is woeful, and while there is no lack of heart or commitment in this Welsh team, they just don’t look the unified unit that got them to Tier 1 of the WXV last year. Their fixture list doesn’t really get any easier with a tough trip to a rejuvenated Ireland. They then have the luxury of facing France and Italy at home as their last two games, but we have a hunch that both these sides will have some serious momentum behind them by that stage that could well be a tough ask for Wales.

Like we say, though, we’ve thoroughly enjoyed this year’s edition so far, and the tournament looks set to continue to grow in popularity and grow the Women’s game further.

Super Rugby finally looks not to be all about New Zealand this year

The proof of the pudding remains to be in the eating come the playoffs, but there does look to be some genuine promise from Australian sides this year, while the Drua are clearly determined to make Fiji’s success at the World Cup a statement of intent

Well so far it’s not been so one sided in favor of the Kiwis, with the expected demise of back to back Champions for the last seven years, New Zealand’s Crusaders, seemingly on the cards at least for this year anyway. Australian sides have looked competitive, particularly the Reds and the Brumbies, but then they always do at the beginning of the season. The Fijian Drua seem impossible to beat at home in Fiji, even if judging by last weekend’s game against Australia’s Western Force, surfing skills will also need to be added to rugby player’s considerable range of talents.

Of the New Zealand teams who still look the primary force in the competition, it appears to be heading towards a final between the Hurricanes and the Chiefs, but the Blues may have a lot to say about this. The Chiefs were runners up last year, but so far this year it all seems to be about the Hurricanes, though the recent potentially season ending injury to their all star scrum half Cameron Roigard could significantly change this outlook as well as getting new All Black Coach Scott Robertson sweating. As mentioned above the Crusaders under new management in the Coaching box are nowhere to be found so far, although last weekend’s first win of the season against the Chiefs could be a season defining moment for them, causing us all to eat our words – seven years of pedigree doesn’t quite vanish overnight. The Highlanders meanwhile seem to be the New Zealand team that simply can’t cut the mustard and, despite some heroic performances at times, have only managed 2 wins.

However, across the Tasman, the Brumbies, as they always do look the strongest Australian side, having won five of their six games. However, of those five wins, only one was against perpetual Kiwi strugglers, the Highlanders, with all other games against Australian sides and Moana Pasifika with their one loss coming at the hands of New Zealand’s Chiefs. The Reds, however, can feel slightly more optimistic as in their two matches against New Zealand opposition, they managed a win over the Chiefs and pushed the Hurricanes hard in Wellington. As the season now takes it’s traditional mid season slow down, it will be hard to really gauge where Australian sides sit in the competition, with the Force nowhere near where they need to be in the standings at the bottom of the table closely followed by the Waratahs. The Melbourne Rebels despite financial ruin staring them in the face have managed to do surprisingly well against the odds, but nevertheless were soundly beaten in their solitary trans Tasman expedition to face the Hurricanes and struggled to scratch out a win against Moana Pasifika.

For us, though, it’s the Fijian Drua who are providing all the excitement this tournament. Having even more home games this year than they did last year is clearly paying dividends. Although they got off to a shaky start against the Blues in Auckland, they have got steadily better as the tournament has progressed, and at home in Fiji, they would appear invincible. We’d be hard pressed to say that we didn’t enjoy their recent water polo match against the Western Force in Lautoka. While life on the road hasn’t been all that kind to them, losing to the Blues, Chiefs and Moana Pasifika, they’ve shown some definite promise and we fancy their chances against the Rebels this weekend in Melbourne. Either way it’s nonstop entertainment watching them in action and we think we can safely say that a spot in the knockouts is assured especially with two of their final five games at home, and a win on the road against either the Rebels or the Force, or preferably both, a distinct possibility.

Spare a thought for the other Pacific Island side, Moana Pasifika, who, although not based in the Islands, will play one game in Tonga against the Highlanders. Although they do have a win over the Drua to their name and also managed to push the Rebels to the limit, this is a side that has 110% heart but consistently falls short in the results department with some very challenging fixtures ahead of them to finish out their season. Still, we have a hunch that the game in Tonga should be a classic and one you definitely won’t want to miss.

Ireland, as expected, hung onto the silverware, and France finally managed to put the disappointment of the World Cup behind them, but both sides still have plenty of work to do for the future

Probably the most competitive Six Nations post a World Cup we can ever remember saw Ireland triumph, albeit with some teething problems, while France finally snapped out of their post World Cup stupor albeit a little bit later than they should have

Well, it’s over for another year, but what a marvelous tournament it ended up being, and definitely the best post World Cup Six Nations we can ever remember. We did not fully jump on the Ireland hype train that their national media did, and definitely held firm to the belief that a Grand Slam was not in the mix this year for the Men in Green. However, we did find it hard to think that anyone else was going to wrestle the trophy away from them after that commanding opening performance against France. At times, Ireland were not quite where they needed to be, and towards the end of the tournament, were surely breathing a sigh of relief that the opener against France had gone so well. England seriously upset their apple cart and outplayed them at their own game, while Scotland pushed them hard all the way to the final whistle.

Nevertheless, Ireland can look back on a campaign that has laid some solid building blocks for the future. Jack Crowley has picked up where Jonathan Sexton left off at fly half, and in Calvin Nash and Joe McCarthy Ireland’s future stocks look very bright indeed. The front row could still use some work, as could the back row, particularly if this year’s Captain Peter O’Mahony really does hang up his legendary boots for good. However, Ireland scored more tries than anyone else by quite some margin, and their defensive work as always was phenomenal. They made more meters than any other team and passed the ball more. They led the numbers in terms of line breaks, were second in lineout steals only to England, and despite their scrum creaking at times still had the second most dominant scrum.

Where they won’t be happy is their lineout work, which was sadly suspect at times, and they missed a few more tackles than a team that has been called the world’s best should at this level. Nevertheless, their work at the breakdown is remarkable, and their reign as turnover kings is second only to Italy of all people while they hang onto their crown of the fastest ruck operators in the business. In short, lots to look forward to ahead of a crucial two Test Tour to South Africa this summer which will really determine whether or not they can legitimately call themselves the “best team in the world” or not. For us, there are plenty of reasons to be optimistic, but the jury is still most definitely out on that call.

Let’s be honest, France looked in danger of having one of their worst Six Nations ever, adding to the earth-shattering disappointment of the World Cup and the seemingly inevitable axing of Head Coach Fabien Galthie. However, as we suspected it eventually would, the Tylenol Extra and black coffee finally took effect, and against Wales, France snapped out of their World Cup hangover. They proved that French rugby can breathe and put on the razzle dazzle without Antoine Dupont in the shape of Nolann Le Garrec, who is now surely France’s first choice number nine in the absence of “le petit general”. France, much like Ireland, cautiously put some new talent on display, and by the end of the tournament, it was finally starting to deliver some much needed results. There is still plenty of fine tuning required, but when you consider how young this team already was, its strong second place finish is a testament to the fact that as painful as it was, the World Cup was simply a hiccough on the road to bigger and better things.

With Thomas Ramos, France had an assured points kicker, despite his odd wobble and being forced into the ten jersey for the final two games of the tournament. With Damian Penaud out wide on the wing they also had this year’s King of the line break. However, although they had rallied by the end of the tournament, and their remarkable offloading game was back on song, that characteristically stalwart and almost impenetrable French defense was hard to spot at times this Championship. They consistently made their tackles and their overall success rate in this department was one of the best in the competition, but their defensive shape often lacked the structure we’re used to seeing and at times was downright porous. By the time the tournament wrapped up they seemed to have started rebuilding Fortress “Les Bleus” but its absence at times in the opening three rounds was quite an eye opener and something which their opponents for the remainder of the year will have taken careful note of. While they had the most successful scrum of the competition, they will be seriously concerned with their lineout efficiency, which was decidedly sketchy at times.

It wasn’t a Six Nations to remember for France, but by the time it wrapped up in Lyon, there was a genuine belief that France are back and mean business. With various key players such as Romain Ntamack and Antoine Dupont returning to the fold during the course of the coming months, expect France to pick up where they left off after last Year’s Six Nations – perhaps not quite as shiny but still a force to be reckoned with in no uncertain terms.

England are back people, so watch this space, while Scotland are left wondering why a side that promises so much ultimately delivers so little

England showed that their World Cup form was no flash in the pan, and now they actually have an attacking game to boot. Scotland meanwhile were consistently inconsistent despite some stunning performances.

We had a hunch that England were only going to get better after they ended up with a bronze medal at the World Cup, much to practically everyone’s surprise, including it would seem their own. They may not have been the world’s most exciting team, mainly because their attacking game was almost nonexistent, but they knew how to grind out wins. They built on that quality this Six Nations but also managed to add an attacking game that shows genuine promise. They struggled to get past Italy in the opening round, but still got the job done and then made hard work of containing a Welsh side that simply refused to be in awe of their more experienced opponents. Question marks were being raised by the time they got on the bus for the now exceptionally difficult encounter with their nemesis of the last few years Scotland. Had England simply been a flash in the pan at the World Cup with a lucky draw, or had they genuinely turned a corner?

We’d argue that England were struggling simply because they were trying to answer their critics by developing an attacking game. They were clearly trying out a new style and trying to blend it into their exceptionally capable defensive platform. At times, England was clearly having teething problems with the process, and Scotland exposed it to the full, as they beat their opponents from South of Hadrian’s Wall yet again. However, what followed 2 weeks later was one of the best games of the tournament as England went full throttle Irish on Ireland. They had clearly decided that the only way to beat Ireland was to play Ireland’s breakneck game in attack and defense but do it better than the Men in Green, which is precisely what they did for a full eighty minutes at Twickenham. It was all a little bit too close for comfort at times, with Ireland gaining the ascendancy in the final quarter with only a last second drop goal from fly half Marcus Smith sealing the deal for England at the death. Nevertheless, it was one of the most exciting games of the Championship with England showing some genuine flair and style on attack at times. The ultimate agonizing two point loss to France at the death was a bitter pill to swallow, but the future looks bright indeed for the much maligned Head Coach Steve Borthwick and his charges. Their two Test series in New Zealand this summer will be a genuine insight into how far England have come in the last year.

In terms of how far their attacking game has come since the World Cup, it’s interesting to note that they were second only to Ireland in terms of line breaks this Six Nations, a statistic which find of the year back rower Ben Earl played a huge part in. However, one area they won’t be happy with is their tackle success rate, which was one of the worst in the competition, and was blatantly obvious at times, especially against France. Their lineout work was for the most part solid along with much of their set piece work and although their discipline could have been better on occasion for the most part it was markedly improved from the Eddie Jones era. England are back people and mean business, with a fascinating but exciting year ahead of them.

Scotland retained their title this Six Nations of being the most frustrating team on the planet to watch/support. They are a fabulous team make no mistake who play a divinely inspired game of rugby at times. The problem is that they simply can’t do it with any degree of consistency whatsoever, and as a result we’re left humming the same funeral march every year – so much promise but so little to show for it. Sure, they managed their now traditional rout of England, but that’s the only major aspect of this Six Nations they ended up getting to cheer about. Admittedly, they didn’t quite fade into obscurity in the latter half of the Championship as they have done with alarming regularity for the last few years. To be fair to them, all their games were close, and some could still argue that had that try at the death against France have been allowed we would have all been singing a much different tune. However, the point is that it wasn’t and Scotland ultimately lost their three games through a lack of killer instinct and that said trait almost caused them to throw their opening game against Wales, which they managed to win by only one point.

The sad reality with Scotland is that they are simply not an 80-minute ruthlessly efficient team. They have some truly god given talent but it all counts for very little if you can only apply it for 65 minutes or so and then decide to take a mid match nap, leaving yourself scrambling in those final 5 minutes to snatch a win from the jaws of defeat and expose yourself to all the mistakes that come with such pressure. In short, a side that on paper has no need to play desperation rugby invariably does so in the final ten minutes. Such traits sadly do not win Championships, let alone World Cups. This theme has become such a broken record with Scotland that we have simply run out of answers. We think it lies somewhat deeper than leadership on or off the pitch or in the Coaching box. However, as Scotland’s longest serving Coach, questions are no doubt being asked about the longevity of Gregor Townsend as he appears unable to fix this quintessential Scottish stumbling block.

It’s not all gloom and doom as Scotland led the offload statistics this Six Nations even if some of them were wildly optimistic and ended up costing Finn Russell and his teammates valuable possession. They also tackled like demons and led the tournament in terms of tackle success rate. Clearly, the work they did on defensive systems this past few months paid some dividends. However, their scrum and set piece work was an absolute disaster and caused them to leak more penalties as a result than any other side. Nevertheless, put all the statistics aside, both good and bad, and it’s still that lack of focus at key moments that trips Scotland up every time. Somehow, it needs to be fixed and quickly as you get the sense that Scottish supporters are starting to question if their side’s promise is merely nothing more than smoke and mirrors. We sincerely hope for their sake that it’s not, and Scottish rugby finds the supplies of collective espresso it needs.

“Viva Italia” finally has a positive and meaningful ring to it, while Wales, despite the abyss they find themselves staring into, should take heart

After all the talk and false dawns, Italy finally arrive at the Six Nations party and can claim the right to stay after 24 years. Meanwhile in Wales although the state of the game in the Principality is in freefall without a parachute, there was some tremendous heart and grit put on display by their team this Six Nations that should give them grounds for optimism and their opponents cause for concern come the next World Cup

Viva ITALIA!!!! We have to be honest and say we’ve been wanting to shout this for the last 24 years, and even though we have been able to do so at times in the past it’s been hard to do it with any long lasting conviction. Well, not so this year! What a fabulous tournament from the Azurri, and if that kick at the final whistle in Lille in Round Three against France had gone through the uprights, it would have been Italy’s greatest feat and finish in a tournament in their proud history. New Coach Gonzalo Quesada has taken the building blocks put in place by his predecessor Kieran Crowley and turned them into foundations of steel. It’s always been a joy to watch Italy in the last few years, but invariably one that ends on a note of intense frustration. Well, we’re pleased to say not this year, and Italy finally appear to have turned a corner.

Italy have shown increasing skill in the last few years and a genuinely exciting attacking game, however in the same breadth Italy would be guilty of extreme impatience and their players getting caught up in the heat of the moment with decision making, discipline and skills suffering as a result. The essential difference this year was that they finally showed some composure and patience, and it paid huge dividends. They made smart and informed decisions and took chances when they were on but were equally comfortable playing it safe when necessary. Their ambition, which had often appeared reckless in seasons gone by, looked controlled and well managed. In short, this was such a positive Italian campaign, and the future finally looks very bright indeed. While Italy won’t be happy with the fact that they missed more tackles than any other team this Six Nations, they will take some solid comfort in the fact that they had more breakdown steals than any other team, including Ireland for whom that is traditionally a bread and butter statistic. There are still plenty of things to work on, particularly in the set pieces though across the board Italy fared much better in terms of success than they normally do and their scrum showed significant improvement, while Federico Ruzza was a constant menace in any lineout he appeared in. Captain Michele Lamaro led from the front and made more tackles than any other player in the tournament, while for us the midfield pairing of Juan Ignacio Brex and Tommaso Menoncello was one of the best of the entire Championship.

In short, there is so much to be excited about an Italian side that finally appears to have arrived after years of false dawns. We can’t wait for the Autumn Nations series, which sees them test their mettle against New Zealand and Argentina. The wins against Wales and Scotland were outstanding achievements, and that agonizing draw with France was still a cause for celebration. In all honesty Italy’s only negative this Six Nations was that 36-0 blowout against Ireland in Dublin, but we have a hunch is one they learnt a great deal from which they clearly demonstrated in the final three rounds.

As for Wales, we offer our heartfelt commiserations to a side left clutching the Wooden Spoon. You simply can’t fault Wales for the effort that Warren Gatland’s young and rather inexperienced side put in. They were often predicted to be lambs to the slaughter against bigger opponents but still managed to put up a fight that left many of their opponents having to dig deep. They were outclassed by tournament favorites Ireland and a French outfit that finally found their groove, but for the rest of the tournament, although they finished winless, they can still hold their heads high.

Coach Warren Gatland chose one of the youngest and most inexperienced squads to ever don the famous red jersey. While that lack of experience was there for all to see throughout the tournament, Wales never looked in awe of the monumental task in front of them. The only time we really thought they felt themselves genuinely outclassed was in that third round match against Ireland. They reveled in the opportunity to expose Scotland’s lack of focus in Round One and came within one point of getting the Scots off to a truly miserable start in their own backyard. They appeared completely unfazed by playing in front of the 80,000 Twickenham faithful and caused England all sorts of problems and were unlucky to lose that game by a mere two points, having lost to Scotland by only 1 point a week earlier. The Italian game was a bitter pill to swallow especially at home, but once again it wasn’t for the want of trying, but it was clear that a grueling five week campaign and such a young and inexperienced group had little left in the tank for one last hurrah. However, once again to their credit, even if it wasn’t particularly well organized or executed Wales threw the kitchen sink at the Italians, even if they only managed to find said sink in the changing rooms at half time.

There were some rays of light in this Welsh campaign though despite the humility of stirring the Six Nations pot with the Wooden Spoon. Their lineout was one of the best in the competition, and they actually won more of their own lineouts than any other team. Back rower Tommy Refell, or “Turnover Tommy” as he is more accurately known, had more breakdown steals than any other player in the tournament. Wales young Captain Dafydd Jenkins was an inspirational leader on and off the pitch and was huge in the rucks for Wales. Cameron Winnett was a revelation at fullback, even though he had only played a grand total of 16 games of professional rugby prior to the start of the Six Nations, and Rio Dyer on the wing was sensational. Question marks remain as to who can fill Dan Biggar’s boots at fly half, and that is a debate that is unlikely to be resolved any time soon, but as we say despite the lack of results we’d argue it actually wasn’t such a bad Six Nations for Wales as some are making it out to be.

It’s a refit for the future as far as Wales is concerned, and given the turmoil in the game at the domestic level, we’d argue it’s a pretty good starting point with some significant promise. We also appreciated the way in which Coach Warren Gatland let his players express themselves, even if it proved costly at times, rather than lock them into his traditional “Warrenball” straitjackets. Wales now look ahead to a two Test Tour to Australia this summer, a country which finds itself in a similar rugby crisis to themselves. Consequently, with the Six Nations and the chance to allow this new team to gel accomplished, the Tour to Australia could be a golden opportunity to achieve some big results against a team that has yet to find its feet under new management. We have a hunch it could be one of the most fascinating of all the summer tours and have a sneaking suspicion Wales are going to come out of it with some degree of credit. We can’t wait to find out!

Well, that’s it for this week, folks, and sorry, this has been rather a long time coming, but life just seems remarkably busy these days. So onwards and upwards, and here’s looking forward to the business ends of Super Rugby, the Champions Cup, and the URC as well as a fabulous Women’s Six Nations!

Lineout Calls of the Week – Six Nations Super Saturday

Is there anything else to really talk about this week in all honesty other than the penultimate end to what has been an enthralling Six Nations? This Super Saturday, as the tournament’s final weekend has come to be known, is going to be one of the most exciting in the competition’s 24-year history as a group of six fierce competitors.

Four teams are still in it to win it even though Ireland have a commanding lead on the points table, despite coming unstuck against England last weekend. England have been quietly in the hunt since the beginning, and if not for that unfortunate and costly wobble at Murrayfield in Round 3, would be the only side heading into the final Round unbeaten. Scotland although sitting in third place heading into the final weekend, are there by the skin of their teeth and have demonstrated their end of tournament customary fadeout by losing to Italy last weekend, and another difficult trip to Dublin awaits them this Saturday. France would seem to have finally recovered from their World Cup hangover if last weekend’s second half annihilation of Wales is anything to go by, even if their final game on home soil is against an English side that looked nothing short of awesome against Ireland. Italy would finally appear to have developed the ability to win big games and have been exceptionally competitive all tournament with the only real blip on the radar being found asleep at the wheel against Ireland in Round 2. Last but not least its been a strange but highly courageous tournament for Wales, despite them staring at the handle of the Wooden Spoon on Saturday, especially if they come unstuck against an exceptionally feisty and confident Italian side. This young and inexperienced Welsh side has certainly not been intimidated by the bright lights, and given it’s only year one of the next World Cup cycle, there is plenty to be excited about for the future.

So no, we’re not going to go into the various mathematical permutations of who needs to get what to finish where. Instead, what got us talking this week, especially looking over the team sheets is where we think the teams might stand come the final points table allied to a player that is likely to loom large in the respective Coaches’ plans for making that happen on Saturday and likely to be a big part of their future plans. We did cover all six teams but unfortunately on publishing for reasons best known to WordPress it deleted the sections on Scotland, Italy and France and we have been unable to recover them, so our apologies and we’re out of time. However, we have covered all three matches over on the Podcast see the link on the TV Page.

Ireland – No Grand Slam this year, but still the team to beat!


Andy Farrell will feel more than pleased with Ireland’s tournament, as although historic Grand Slams are no longer in the offing, he and his charges have learnt a great deal about themselves and the transition from the Sexton glory years to the Jack Crowley era has been almost seamless

Ireland’s one point loss to England at Twickenham last weekend, and with it a shot at historic back to back Grand Slams, was a setback on their march to Six Nations glory, but one they almost seemed to relish and with it the chance to embrace the lessons they needed to learn from it. Let’s be honest, Ireland had not really been tested until they arrived at Twickenham. Despite the opening game in Marseille against joint tournament favorites France being prematurely being billed the tournament decider – it simply wasn’t. France arrived still nursing an almighty World Cup hangover, allowing Ireland to keep them in check with relative ease. They then breezed past an Italian side still coming to grips with the way they could and should play under new Coach Gonzalo Quesada, and much the same could be said two weeks later as Ireland sailed past Wales without ever really having to get out of third gear.

Unlike the Irish media, who, after England’s loss to Scotland, essentially made the rather arrogant assumption that a Grand Slam was in the bag, we never felt the game at Twickenham was going to be easy. England had only suffered one loss and were quietly building towards something, even if they were tripping over their bootlaces at times and didn’t look overly confident in the process. We weren’t alone as you sensed the team, and most Irish supporters felt the same way. England were waiting to click into gear, and what better opportunity than to put one of the World’s best sides in their place on your home ground. That’s what happened last Saturday at Twickenham, and had George Ford brought his kicking boots with him, then it would have been a much more dominant scoreline than just the one point win in favor of England.

Ireland are a very good team, make no mistake, and we’d still be bold enough to say that they are the most complete side in the Championship. Ireland have dominated a large chunk of the statistics this tournament both at individual and team level. However, what happened last Saturday was that England were better at being Ireland than the Irish were at being themselves. The mark of great sides, such as the All Black squad from 2011 to 2019, was their ability to adapt on the pitch when things clearly weren’t going their way, and change things up if necessary. If there is a lesson Ireland needed to learn from last Saturday’s dustup at Twickenham, it’s that. Ireland kept playing as Ireland even though England essentially copied them and were, for all intents, better at playing the Irish game plan. Ireland have become so sure that their frenetic attack and blitz defense can overwhelm teams, they seem almost unsure of themselves when a team can match it play for play as England did last Saturday.

That’s where Jack Crowley comes in as perhaps the most important player in Andy Farrell’s plans going forward, and how to deal with a Scottish side who will come to Dublin with every intention of causing an upset and possessing the skill set to do it. Crowley will need to pull the strings when Plan A clearly isn’t working. What we’ve seen of him so far leads us to believe that he is the player to do and shows a creativity and ability to think on his feet that Sexton in his latter years wasn’t as comfortable with. Crowley is still developing his own style of how he wants to conduct the Irish symphony, but is not burdened by the aura or expectation that surrounded his predecessor.

In short, he’s much more of a free spirit and from what we’ve seen so far has an excellent eye for space and how to use it, while also much like his predecessor not shy of putting his body on the line for his teammates if that is what is required. The essential difference we feel though is that he is more prone to hang back and get a feel of the flow of the game, rather than rush headlong into the fray as Sexton was at times all too eager to do, resulting in a breakdown of communication and timing. Crowley has shown a calmness that belies his youth and which bodes well for the future. We simply haven’t seen him panic yet, and considering this is only his first year of picking up where Sexton left off, that’s an impressive quality indeed. We have a hunch that Andy Farrell has big plans for the Munster youngster, both with Ireland and the Lions next year.

Saturday’s tussle with Scotland must see Ireland be able to think on their feet, trust in their tried and proven processes, but also change things up when needed. There is a humility and eagerness to learn in this side, even if their media doesn’t reflect it, that should serve them well enough to get them home this Saturday in Dublin and lift one of the sport’s most cherished pieces of silverware for the second year in a row.

England are getting there make no mistake, despite the barrage of criticism they’ve been subjected to

England Coach Steve Borthwick has copped his fair share of criticism in the past year, but his charges are really starting to click and the platform that extraordinary back rower Ben Earl provides them both in attack and defense is proving rather formidable

We’ll put our hands up and be the first to say that we are guilty as charged if we’ve been less than positive about England at times so far this Six Nations. However, all that aside we were in awe of the performance England put in at Twickenham last Saturday. That was THE best English performance we’ve seen since the World Cup in 2019 plain and simple. It was cohesive, ferocious and meticulous in its execution against one of the best sides in the world. England rarely missed a beat and had George Ford brought his kicking boots the winning margin would have been even bigger. What’s more England’s attacking game showed a truckload of ambition and skill while, unlike in the first three Rounds, it was implemented with precision and confidence. In short, England are back and a French side who look to be coming out of their Post World Cup coma, will no doubt be feeling more than a little anxious about this Saturday’s meeting in Lyon with the Red Rose. In the space of a fortnight all England’s problems, so painfully in evidence at Murrayfield, were fixed. They clearly did their homework on the Irish and decided the best way to beat them was to play as Ireland themselves. That’s precisely what they did and were the better team on the day.

The statistics make for impressive reading, against Scotland England made 25 handling errors while against Ireland they only made 13, and passed the ball only slightly less. The game was played at a furious pace and intensity but there was a focus and sense of understanding of what they needed to do and how to do it under the kind of relentless pressure a side like Ireland can put you under. In short, this was a very good performance indeed and we’d argue one of the best games of the Championship so far. It will be an enormous confidence booster ahead of a tough trip to France.

Some have criticized Marcus Smith who came off the bench at fly half for George Ford, choosing to go for a guaranteed drop goal at the death when England had advantage and could have kicked for the corner and a bonus point try. We think Smith made the right choice, and in doing so won the match for England. That win more than anything is what England really needed at this stage in their development. There are three more Six Nations before the next World Cup. England are still a work in progress but it’s wins that are needed at the moment rather than trophies. There was absolutely no guarantee, given the quality of Ireland’s defensive structures, that England would have been able to maul it over the try line at the death – whereas that drop goal was a gifted certainty.

However, what perhaps impressed us the most about England’s performance was the superhuman effort from England’s number 8 Ben Earl. He had already emerged as England’s most important player at the end of the World Cup, but his performance last Saturday at Twickenham had to be seen to be believed. If he doesn’t get the nod as the best number 8 of the tournament then there really is no rugby justice. Earl’s importance to the way England want to play simply cannot be understated. He is rapidly becoming the linchpin in how this England side gets over the gain line, while at the same time disrupting any kind of flow or rhythm of England’s opponents. He is the catalyst both in attack and defense which is making the rest of his forward pack increasingly effective. His ability to carry the ball and break open defenses is becoming legendary, and in terms of meters carried he sits just behind Ireland’s James Lowe on the tournament stats table.

Earl’s abilities are more than just a rampaging back rower. This is a very well rounded rugby player who makes the role of a loose forward look like a craft, much more so than the one dimensional nature of some of his predecessors such as Eddie Jones’ favorite Billy Vunipola. Some of his offloads both under pressure and even in the tackle have been exceptional, and demonstrate a strength and skill set that is rapidly making him a linchpin of how Coach Steve Borthwick wants the team to move forward. In the game plan that England is developing expect to see a lot of it built around the skills and strengths that Earl brings to the table, both in attack and defense. Earl can rattle opposition sides by getting in their faces but at the same time maintaining his composure and discipline, if you ever could define a player in terms of controlled raw aggression then Earl fits the bill rather well.

It will be a big ask of England to travel to France with their new set of blueprints and put them into practice successfully against a French side with everything to prove. However, the weight of expectation in Lyon on Saturday is ALL on France and it tripped them up in the World Cup. As a result we have a sense that England may well be relishing the underdog label this weekend, and either way a strong finish is on the cards in this year’s tournament for Borthwick and his men.

France are emerging from their post World Cup hangover a little too late, but the signs are promising

Fabien Galthie’s tenure as Head Coach has been under the microscope since that World Cup quarter final defeat, but a solid win over England this weekend in Lyon would do much to restore integrity back to a battered French outfit both in the Coaching box and on the pitch

Let’s face it, it hasn’t been exactly fun times for Fabien Galthie and his charges this Six Nations. First there was the challenge of adapting to life without superstar Antoine Dupont in the scrum half berth, and to be honest until last Sunday in Cardiff that hasn’t gone that well. Then there was the difficulty in coming to terms with France’s premature exit from the World Cup. That in itself seems to have been the biggest hurdle to French progress in the last few months. France are simply not themselves either in the Coaching box or on the pitch. All that appeared to change last Sunday in Cardiff, but this weekend’s action in Lyon will confirm whether or not France really have emerged from their post World Cup malaise.

France have been an interesting conundrum this Six Nations, in that they haven’t exactly been awful and when you look at their overall statistics it doesn’t show a dominant French side vis a vis the rest of the competitors, but it doesn’t make for grim reading either. For example, their defensive stats while not quite up to their usual high standards are still nevertheless fairly robust. Their scrum success rate is the best in the competition, yet watching France since February, that clinical and well structured approach just doesn’t appear to be there. We’re not the first to comment on the fact that although their defensive stats wouldn’t necessarily set alarm bells ringing, there has been little doubt that while watching France’s defense in action on our TV screens this past two months, it has looked surprisingly and uncharacteristically porous at times. When it does all click they are amazing to watch but, that confidence that was so prevalent in everything they did last year up until the World Cup appears to be lacking.

However, last Sunday in Cardiff the sleeping giant that is France appeared to waken from its post World Cup stupor. If you ask us it was all down to a certain gentleman wearing the number 9 jersey. The legacy of Antione Dupont and his absence from proceedings this Six Nations seemed to leave the French squad in a state of confusion as to what game they should be playing and how to execute, with hardly anyone singing from the same song sheet to make matter worse. Enter Racing 92 scrum half Nolan le Garrec stage left, last Sunday in Cardiff. All of a sudden with him starting for France they finally started to click.

Although Maxime Lucu is a fine player in the position, his value added seems much greater as an impact player off the bench. Right from the get go le Garrec set the tone of what kind of game France were going to play and everybody seemed to understand what was required of them. Le Garrec’s ability to link his forwards to his backs and ability to make split second decisions was more akin to what France were used to under Dupont’s tenure. At long last France’s prowess on both attack and defense reasserted itself. In short, the disjointed French side we’d seen up till then was no longer in evidence.

For his efforts le Garrec has been rewarded with the starting berth in the 9 jersey for Le Crunch match with England this Saturday in Lyon. In him, Coach Galthie appears to have found a replacement for “le petit general” that he can rely on. The way France is structured at the moment that role is vital and as evidenced in the World Cup, when not there France look vulnerable. Looking to the future the ability to interchange between le Garrec, provided he passes the big test on Saturday, and Dupont will be critical to French plans going forward and with a view to Australia in 2027. He’ll be France’s most important player on Saturday, and it will be fascinating to see how well he copes with the weight of expectation of a nation.

So like we say no disrespect to Scotland, Italy and Wales but unfortunately technology decided to censor them this week. A thousand apologies, but there is a ton of content from our good mates Squidge, Two Cents, Riaan Louw and Eggchasers and our usual Podcast available on Spotify and other platforms over on the TV page for you to sink your teeth into and ponder so enjoy what should be an epic Super Saturday!

Lineout Calls of the Week

Well, it’s Six Nations time once more and some very tasty and indeed intriguing fixtures on the table this weekend. Wales look like no slackers despite their youth and relative inexperience, but can they really take on the Irish juggernaut on their home soil at the Aviva? Then, in one of our favorite fixtures of the tournament, can England wrestle back the Calcutta Cup from the Scots who have kept it locked away in Murrayfield’s deepest vault for the last three years? Last but not least a fascinating encounter awaits in Lille as France who are a long way off from firing on all cylinders host an Italian outfit that shows plenty of promise if they can simply be patient and master the basics. Lille is not one of France’s traditional rugby heartlands, and can the Italians use it to their advantage and treat it almost like a neutral ground?

In addition to the Six Nations, rugby in the Southern Hemisphere kicks into gear with the start of the Super Rugby Pacific season. There are so many questions to be answered. Can Australian sides, despite the massive upheaval and uncertainty going on in Australian rugby, actually be competitive this year, or will the tournament dissolve into a New Zealand domestic competition as it approaches its business end. Will everybody’s second team, the Fijian Drua, build on the success of the national side last year at the World Cup? Is the Crusaders remarkable seven year dominance of the tournament finally over now their Coach Scott “Razor” Robertson has moved on to the take the reins of the All Blacks Coaching job?

These were the main talking points for us this week, but there is also that intriguing little matter of South Africa opening their Test season this year at Twickenham in June against Wales, something which looks set to become par for the course in terms of the International Calendar in the coming years. Good for the game or just a money grab? We’d argue a bit of both.

So with so much to talk about, let’s get stuck into what kept our pints frothy this week.

South Africa clearly have a soft spot for Twickenham

Is Twickenham set to become the Loftus Versfeld of the North for the Springboks as they prepare to host Wales at the famous stadium in June to kickstart their season?

We’re beginning to get the impression that Twickenham is starting to feel like a comfortable old blanket for the Springboks. Look at the sea of green and gold that filled England HQ as they gave the All Blacks a schooling last August, and it’s easy to see why. The South African community in London is massive, and they all love and miss their rugby. Consequently, having their idols play essentially a home game in London is a dream come true for those suffering more than just a touch of homesickness. Add to this the significant injection of hard currency into SARU’s coffers, and it’s no surprise that they jumped at the opportunity.

Wales themselves, while probably wanting to play at the Principality and their own home ground, certainly won’t mind cashing in on the profits to be made from playing such a fixture in London, especially now Taylor Swift has booted them out of Cardiff for that proposed date anyway. Given the parlous state of finances that Welsh rugby is faced with, any opportunity to jump on the bandwagon of a cash cow won’t go amiss.

So put all the finances aside, and ask yourselves the question of whether or not this is too much rugby and who will be available on the proposed fixture date of June 22nd. If you were Irish, Scottish or possibly even Italian you might feel a bit peeved knowing that the final of the United Rugby Championship will also be taking place on that day, and therefore not have your best players available to face the World Champions. However, the harsh reality is that most Welsh teams will be well out of the URC by that stage, and only a handful of players playing in the English Premiership or French Top 14 will be affected. In the case of South Africa, only one of their URC teams is likely to be in the final unless Leinster or Glasgow suffer some massive end of season dip in form. Admittedly some of the best Springboks are still likely to be wrapping up their contractual obligations in the TOP 14 and English Premiership, but a sizeable proportion of the World Cup winning squad will have finished their club duties in Japan and thus be available for this match.

As a result, both teams should be able to put together pretty respectable sides that can do the occasion justice. It will be excellent preparation for Wales’ tour of Australia the next month, while South Africa will be getting spooled up to host Ireland and then the Rugby Championship. While initially it all looked a bit forced we actually think that if managed properly this could end up being a worthwhile fixture for both sides, with some very beneficial revenues to be made out of it for both in the process. Furthermore, if it does prove as financially lucrative as it promises to be, expect to see South Africa start their International Season in London on a regular basis.

In short, it’s an interesting proposition, and we can’t wait to see how it pans out and what it means for the future. Either way, it’s likely to be much more of a success than the rather tepid low quality encounter between these two that was held in Washington DC of all places at the same time six years ago.

Super Rugby Pacific – who will provide the spark this tournament desperately needs?

If this year’s Super Rugby Pacific simply dissolves into a New Zealand derby in the knockout stages, as it has done for the last few years, how relevant is it as an International Club tournament?

It’s back, folks, and although it doesn’t quite hold the same thrall for us as the Champions Cup in the Northern Hemisphere, it’s still an entertaining competition. Super Rugby Pacific, since the departure of South African sides in 2021, has definitely lost some of its luster and international flavor. It has been dominated by New Zealand teams since then, with the semis and especially the final being all Kiwi affairs. The arrival of the two Pacific Island sides Moana Pasifika and Fijian Drua spiced things up a bit more, and certainly, the addition of the Fijians has been a welcome and exciting addition. The crisis affecting Australian rugby over the last two years has been magnified in this competition, with the Brumbies being the only side who can consistently hold their own against their New Zealand rivals. The rest of the Australian teams rarely make much of a dent in the competition.

However, it’s not all gloom and doom, and this season throws up some interesting scenarios. While we expect to see New Zealand teams continue to dominate, we very much doubt that the Crusaders who have won the competition for the last 7 years will be lifting the trophy this year. Of the New Zealand sides, most likely to compete for the silverware, we think it will be between the Blues, Hurricanes, and Chiefs. The fan favorites for every neutral and all of us here at the Lineout, the Fijian Drua, are being tipped to go deep into the competition this year. Furthermore, you simply won’t want to miss any of their 7 home games in Fiji, where the atmosphere will be absolutely electric and one which literally pops out of your TV screen and into your living room. If every there was a solid advertisement for growing the game globally, it’s a Drua home game in Fiji. Also, expect to see Moana Pasifika throw the odd unexpected upset into the mix.

As for the Australian sides, it will be one of two scenarios. We hope they finally start to turn a corner and new Wallaby Coach Joe Schmidt is able to look forward to his Tests in charge this summer with some degree of optimism. What we’re hoping we don’t see is a continuing slide, and some franchises such as the Melbourne Rebels disappear forever into history, while Joe Schmidt ends up questioning his career choices. To say that 2024 is a make or break year for Australian rugby is likely to be the understatement of the decade, and it all starts on Friday when the Force meet the Hurricanes.

Sadly, for now, we are feeling more pessimistic than optimistic, but desperately hope that this opening weekend gives us and Australian supporters reasons to be cheerful not just for their own rugby but the competition as a whole. If New Zealand are to remain competitive on the International stage, they need some viable competition at club level and exposure to different playing styles, and Australia will be key to providing that. Without it, New Zealand will head into its International season with little quality overseas exposure if Australian sides remain uncompetitive at Super Rugby level. This could have ramifications for the All Blacks and their success on the International stage despite the genius of their new Coach, Scott Robertson.

In short, there are plenty of questions ahead of the new season and plenty at stake for all parties.

Ireland continue to reach for the stars

Wales know they have an almost impossible task ahead of them this weekend in their bid to put the brakes on the Irish blitzkrieg of this year’s Six Nations in Dublin

Who will derail Ireland? Can a young but ambitious side displaying a bucket load of that hard to quantify quality of Welsh grit get the job done? Or will it be left to either England or Scotland in the cauldrons of Twickenham and Murrayfield? To be honest, having watched Ireland in the opening two rounds, it’s hard to see the Men in Red being the outfit to upset the green apple cart on Saturday in Dublin. There will be plenty of grit and determination on hand, and Wales may at times force Ireland to think on their feet and throw caution to the wind. However, it’s hard to see a relatively inexperienced but courageous Welsh outfit topple the green juggernaut. Ireland have simply looked too good and clinical so far this Six Nations, and in their 36-0 drubbing of Italy two weeks ago they barely had to get into third gear, while their demolition job on France in Marseille in the opening weekend, which many dubbed as the Championship decider, was a well drilled performance of enterprise and efficiency.

As for Wales, we’d argue they have exceeded expectations so far. They simply refused to quit against both Scotland and England, and both those games could have gone either way. In short, write this young but gritty team off at your peril. While an upset of atomic proportions against Ireland in Dublin on Saturday afternoon is most likely fantasy league stuff, expect them to have a genuine crack at tilting windmills.

While we fully expect Wales to be competitive up front in the front and second row exchanges, it’s hard to see them getting the measure of the Irish offering, with the only question mark being Tadgh Furlong who hasn’t quite been at his rampaging best of late for Ireland. However, Wales have really struggled at set piece time with their scrum creaking horrendously at times and their lineout accuracy being especially suspect, though the decision to give Elliot Dee the starting Hooker berth did dramatically improve the Welsh performance in that department against England and we’re relieved that Coach Warren Gatland has kept the faith with Dee this weekend.

It’s a very capable and competitive Welsh back row, with Alex Mann in particular proving to be a revelation so far, having scored a try in both rounds. Tommy Reffell is pedigree through and through, but so is his opponent, Irish firebrand, and Captain Peter O’Mahony. Aaron Wainwright has been immense for Wales, but Ireland’s Caelan Doris is likely to walk away with the label of best number eight if not player of the tournament.

Ireland’s new halfback pairing of Jamison Gibson-Park and Jack Crowley is barely missing a beat since Johnny Sexton’s retirement, but Crowley’s goal kicking would appear to still be a work in progress along with some of the finer aspects of his tactical kicking, but it should still get the better of Wales. Unlike Ireland, Wales still seem to be unsure as to who their long-term replacement for fly half Dan Biggar is, with Sam Costelow getting his second Six Nations audition this year.

In the backs, the Welsh centre pairing of George North and Nick Tompkins certainly made England sit up and take notice of them two weeks ago at Twickenham, but they will have to be at their bravest to stop the Bundee Aki express and Robbie Henshaw’s quick thinking. Calvin Nash is relishing life on the wing for Ireland and seems to be a permanent fixture for the future while James Lowe continues to cause opposition defenses all kinds of headaches as well as a boot that keeps getting the Irish out of tricky situations with ease. The contest between Rio Dyer and Calvin Nash should be one of the most entertaining of the match, with the Welshman missing a few too many tackles for comfort, but no slacker in the speed department. Lastly, Ireland are forced into a change with Hugo Keenan out injured for this one at fullback, and as a result making a spot for utility back Ciaran Frawley to fill his rather large boots. Keenan’s reliability under the high ball and ability to break the gain line are becoming the stuff of legends, and as a result Frawley has some very big boots to fill on Saturday, as he attempts to contain his opposite number for Wales Cameron Winnett. The 21 year old Welshman looks born to the role and has easily been one of Coach Warren Gatland’s most impressive debutants in the red jersey this Six Nations.

This should be a fairly straightforward arm wrestle for Ireland in front of a very vocal and expectant home crowd. Get this one out of the way and all of a sudden Ireland have one hand firmly on the Six Nations trophy and that dream of back to back historic Grand Slams suddenly starts to look like a distinct possibility despite two tough trips to Twickenham and Murrayfield which lay ahead of them. As for Wales, expect further refinement and plenty of heart from Coach Warren Gatland’s young but exceptionally enthusiastic charges. Make no mistake, this is not a Welsh side to be taken lightly, despite its relative youth and inexperience and one which seems undaunted by supposedly stronger opponents. In short, this should be an entertaining contest and one that may require something stronger added to your morning coffee on Saturday.

The Calcutta Cup’s similarity to Braveheart gets stronger every year

As England prepare to storm the castle walls at Murrayfield, Scotland’s raw energy and passion will need to be converted into 80 minutes of pure focus and resolve if they are to keep the famous Cup in their keep for a fourth year running

This was always a great game, and it is steeped in history as one of our sport’s oldest and most prestigious trophies. However, in recent years, it has definitely been one of the highlights of the Six Nations Championship. Always tightly contested and a game won often by the slimmest of margins, in the last few years, it has produced some genuine classics. The last three years though have been all about Scotland, and even if the rest of their Six Nations campaign goes to pot, you feel this is the one they want to win the most – it’s their version of “Le Crunch”. Make no mistake England want it just as badly, especially as the Cup seems to have taken up permanent residency status in Scotland for the last three years, but it perhaps doesn’t have quite the same resonance as it does for the Scots especially when played at Murrayfield as it will be this Saturday.

Scotland, however, remain THE most frustrating team on the planet to get behind. They are one of our fan favourites here at the Lineout, but drive us to drink and elation in equal measure. So let’s get the elephant out of the room, sure Scotland should and could have beaten France at Murrayfield two weeks ago – but the point is they didn’t and they sadly only have themselves to blame. Yes we agree that the try at the death should have been awarded by the TMO and the on field officials, but in the harsh light of day, Scotland had actually lost that game 15 minutes earlier, and a win at the death would have simply glossed over a fundamental problem that until addressed will mean that Scotland will never be a Championship side.

Scotland have some extraordinary talent in their ranks, typified by their exceptional Captain and tactical maestro fly half Finn Russell. However, what they don’t have is focus and the killer instinct to go with it. In both of the opening rounds of this year’s Championship, both against Wales and then France, they had their foot on their opponents jugular, but then, after sixty minutes, invariably seemed to switch off. This was blatantly evident in the first game against Wales where they threw away a 27-0 lead in the second half, and were forced into a period of desperate and chaotic defense which saw them sneak home by one point as Wales scored 26 unanswered points.

In Round 2, they had a disorganized France on the ropes until the 60th minute and then once again proceeded to fall asleep, allowing France to steal the game. Admittedly, Scotland scrambled in the final minute to try and salvage the game, and the debate will rage on for years about that disallowed try, which would have allowed them to snatch it at the death. However, scrambling at the last minute does not win you games or Championships, especially when you’ve spent the last twenty minutes squandering a perfectly good lead. It’s clear that Finn Russell is exasperated by his teammates’ lack of focus, as are Scotland’s long suffering but faithful fans. Is it down to Coaching, a lack of fitness, poor communication and leadership on the pitch or just downright complacency? We simply can’t put our finger on it, but like many are tired of talking Scotland up, as much as we love watching them play.

Consequently, Saturday’s fixture is a perplexing one. This is Scotland’s last home game before a challenging trip to Rome and a potentially tournament wilting excursion to Dublin in the final Round. It just has to be a powerhouse performance for the full eighty minutes if Scotland are going to end this tournament on a high. Implode against England, and Scotland’s confidence, which is always suspect, is likely to hit rock bottom, making those final two road trips exceptionally challenging.

For England, it’s definitely a case of slow and steady wins the race. They head into Round 3 along with Ireland, as the only unbeaten sides so far, but unlike the Irish, they haven’t looked overly convincing in the way in which they’ve gone about it. They managed to eke out a win against Italy in Rome and then struggled to cope with a Welsh side that appeared to suffer no stage fright at Twickenham despite its lack of experience. England still look rather weak on attack, although tactically and defensively, they are looking much sharper these days. Their scrum, however, remains a disaster, but then Scotland’s isn’t much better, so they won’t be losing too much sleep over that while their discipline could also be improved.

We have a hunch that England’s forward pack will get the better of Scotland especially in the tight five, though Ellis Genge really needs to find some of the fire that served him so well in the front row for England during the World Cup. The same could be said of Jamie Ritchie in the back row for Scotland, as he appears to have lost a lot of the combative edge that was so important in last year’s Six Nations. However, the battle of the back rows should be one of the most intense contests of the afternoon and expect Scotland’s Rory Darge and England’s Ben Earl to be grabbing most of the headlines.

If they fire though for the full eighty minutes, then the halfback pairing of Scotland’s Finn Russell and Ben White should be able to put their team on the front foot provided that they can get their forwards and backs singing from the same song sheet for the full eighty minutes. The attacking potential in the Scottish duo is far more dangerous in our opinion than England’s offering of Danny Care and George Ford, and we’re just not convinced that they make an effective partnership, with Care seeming to play better alongside his Harlequins teammate the injured Marcus Smith. However, Ford’s tactical nous and ability to allow England to be comfortable playing without the ball and forcing their opponents to play from deep, served them well in the World Cup even if it weakens the attacking threat England pose.

English Premiership revelations Northampton are well represented in the backs with fullback George Furbank replacing England stalwart Freddie Steward and winger Tommy Freeman keeping his spot on the wing. As impressive as Furbank is for his club, he has yet to impress in an England jersey, and under Eddie Jones, his promise failed to materialize. We like the look of Scotland’s back five and the return of Blair Kinghorn to the fullback position after injury could set some sparks flying, while the center channels look threatening along with the South African contingent of Duhan van der Merwe and Kyle Steyn out wide. If the Scottish unit stays focused on the task at hand and defensively sound for the full eighty minutes on Saturday, we give the Scots the edge in this match over an English unit still looking to gel.

This one really could go either way, though we have a hunch that the Calcutta Cup may be remaining North of Hadrian’s Wall for another year. This is Scotland’s last show in front of the Murrayfield faithful this Six Nations, and they know they need to make a statement ahead of a challenging end to their tournament on the road. England will be desperate to rain on their parade and carry the cherished piece of silverware back to Twickenham at long last, but we have a hunch Scotland have the bigger point to prove on Saturday.

Italy and France attempt to dust off their World Cup blues on a ground that could be the closest thing to a neutral ground for Italy in France’s backyard

Lille may be the closest thing to a neutral ground that Italy can find in France, and with it a golden opportunity to confuse a French side still struggling to make sense of a World Cup that promised so much but delivered so little for them

Like we said earlier, this is perhaps for us the most intriguing of all the fixtures this weekend. The Calcutta Cup match at Murrayfield is the one that we’re most looking forward to, but the dustup in Northern France between Les Bleus and the Azurri is the one whose outcome fascinates us the most. Both teams need a convincing win. France are clearly still reeling from their World Cup disappointments, while Italy under new Coach Gonzalo Quesada looked impressive against England at times. They imploded dramatically against Ireland a week later, but for most of us, that outcome had been on the cards since the fixture list for this year’s Championship was announced, so there were very few surprises there. Where Italy tripped up is that they tried playing their ambitious game plan against a side that was able to shut it down before the plays had even been called. Had Italy been a bit more patient and conservative in their approach to the Irish game, the score line might not have been so painful.

French supporters will hope that their team has finally managed to regroup after a chaotic and disorganised first two Rounds. Admittedly they were able to salvage some pride against Scotland with a win two weeks ago, but one can’t help get the feeling that the Scots handed them that win on a plate after switching off for a crucial fifteen minutes of the game in the second half. Had Scotland managed to find that killer instinct which they so often leave in the changing rooms rather than bringing it with them onto the pitch, we probably would have had to write a very different postscript for that match. As it is, France still look a long way off the form that brought them such success last year and a Grand Slam in 2022. Italy will know this and given that they are playing in a venue that doesn’t exactly live and breathe rugby, they will clearly be fancying their chances if they have learnt the lessons they got given in the opening two rounds.

For Italy, the biggest improvement we can see is the decision to start with Benetton Hooker Giacomo Nicotera. His lineout throwing is vastly superior to Gianmarco Lucchesi, who, for reasons best known to the Italian Coaching staff, has been the starting Hooker in the two opening games of the tournament. Consequently, the lineout is an area where Italy has come undone, particularly against Ireland. Ally Nicotera to Danilo Fischetti and Giosue Zilochhi and the all Benetton front row could cause France some issues in the set pieces, where all three are used to plying their trade together at club level. It’s still a pretty impressive French front row, particularly with Cyril Baille in the mix, but they were certainly less than flash at times against Scotland, and their own lineouts are rather hit and miss affairs. The big talking point is that French second row where Cameron Woki will really need to rediscover his form, especially at lineout time, and the giant Posolo Tuilagi wrecking ball gets his first Test start. For Italy, Federico Ruzza is always a force but became so rattled by Ireland’s set piece dominance that his game disintegrated completely after such a strong showing from the big second rower against England a week before. If Italy’s Niccolo Cannone can keep the Tuilagi behemoth in check, then these could be two very competitive tight five units.

In the back row, the French should pull ahead, as there is little doubt that Italy are really struggling without Lorenzo Cannone to anchor the ship at 8. Nevertheless, France are also bereft of their talisman at number eight Gregory Alldritt, necessitating the Captaincy being handed back to Charles Ollivon. Paul Boudehent is into the starting XV alongside Ollivon along with Francois Cros, who moves to number 8, and provided such an impact off the bench against Scotland a fortnight ago. For Italy, all the talk is of a Test debut for Exeter sensation Ross Vintcent at number eight. He may be untested at this level, but his exploits at Exeter have shown that he certainly has the talent. Nevertheless, we can’t help feeling that overall France’s forward pack have the potential to make short work of their Italian counterparts, particularly if they are able to rattle their confidence early in the proceedings.

What has puzzled us, though, is the scrum half selections on both sides. We just don’t think that the Jallibert/Lucu combination is working for France despite it being so effective at club level, while Italy and Quesada would appear unable to settle on who should wear the number 9 jersey as Paolo Garbisi gets yet another new partner to marshal the forwards in the shape of Carcassone’s Martin Page-Relo. If you ask us, we would have preferred to see the Garbisi brothers reunited for this one, as they looked impressive against England in the opening round. As for France, this surely would have been a golden opportunity for Nolan le Garrec to get the starting 9 jersey, and if Lucu fails to have an impact it remains to be seen how long le Garrec bides his time keeping the bench warm on Sunday.

For Italy, we’re also not quite sure of the rationale of breaking up the Benetton center pairing of Tommaso Menoncello and Juan Ignacio Brex. It’s a highly effective unit, with each player complementing the other’s skill sets. Instead, Menoncello is moved to the wing, and Federico Mori is brought in alongside Brex at the centre. It’s definitely a gamble, but Italy now have two powerful wingers in Menoncello and Monty Ioane who excel at breaking the gain line with a handy turn of pace. France have stuck with Louis Bielle-Biarrey and Damian Penaud out wide, and both provide non-stop excitement with ball in hand even if their defense can be questioned at times. Lastly, Italian wonder kid Ange Capuozzo shores up Italy’s last line of defense at fullback against the consummate professional for France Thomas Ramos. There were glimmers of what Capuozzo can do with ball in hand against Ireland, and we’re hoping that this match will finally see him break free once more, while Ramos has been remarkably quiet by his standards so far this Six Nations.

Everything to play for here for both sides, and is this the chance for Italy to claim their first upset of the tournament? While it’s hard to see France slipping up on home soil, this is clearly the biggest potential banana skin of the weekend. France and Italy invariably end up running each other remarkably close in the Six Nations, and the Italians have a habit of catching France napping, and will want revenge after their drubbing at the hands of the French in the World Cup a few months ago. If Italy get their tails up early and then settle into a rhythm and don’t panic under pressure, this could be one to turn the form books upside down. We can’t wait to find out.

Well, that’s it for this week folks, lots to look forward to, and here’s hoping the Fijian Drua put on a show tonight in Auckland!

Lineout Calls of the Week

With the Six Nations almost upon us, obviously, our attention is starting its seismic shift towards one of our favorite times of the year. However, despite our focus being almost completely centered on International Rugby’s oldest and perhaps most colorful and cherished tournament, the rest of the Rugby World does not act in isolation over the coming weeks. There have been announcements South of the Equator, most noticeably in Australia, which will have serious ramifications on how the Rugby World may look come 2027 and the next World Cup in a Land Down Under.

Nevertheless, with all those pre tournament nerves and first round of selection decisions to be made, it’s the Six Nations that dominates the headlines and which has kept most of our pints frothy and lively. So, without any further adieu, let’s cast our eyes over Coaching appointments in Australia and then get straight into the meat and bones of the next few weeks, our beloved Six Nations.

With Joe Schmidt’s appointment, is there finally something to cheer about in Australian rugby

The appointment of former Ireland and All Black assistant Coach Joe Schmidt should give long suffering Wallaby fans some much needed optimism

The more the rumors grew, the more we all knew that it was both inevitable and ultimately a no-brainer. The appointment of former Ireland Coach Joe Schmidt to the Wallabies job should really come as no surprise after the train wreck of Eddie Jones’ brief tenure, which saw the Wallabies crash out of the World Cup and drop to their lowest ever spot in the World Rankings. Once David Nucifora, the former High Performance Director at the Irish Rugby Football Union was appointed as an advisor to the rebuilding process going on in Australian rugby many of us saw Schmidt as a natural fit with the Wallaby Coaching job. The two know each other exceptionally well, and their experience of retooling Irish rugby from the ground up will be invaluable to Rugby Australia’s own much needed transition. In short, it’s a win-win situation for the Wallabies.

Perhaps the one area for confusion is the fact that Schmidt is only contracted till the end of 2025. As everyone who reads this blog knows we are definitely not fans of changing Coaches midway through a World Cup cycle. However, you can see what the thinking is, especially with a British and Irish Lions tour to Australia next summer. Given the dire straits Australian rugby and the Wallabies find themselves in, that Lions Tour is an absolutely critical benchmark as to whether or not the Wallabies are fixable or not. In their present state, most people are predicting a Lions whitewash next year. As a result who better to prepare for it than a Coach and former Performance Director who have an intimate knowledge of the Irish, as well as exposure to the other British Isles teams through numerous Six Nations campaigns.

As for Schmidt’s tenure with the Wallabies post 2025, that remains to be seen. One of the main reasons he gave up the Ireland job in 2019 irrespective of Ireland’s disappointing exit from the World Cup that year, is that he wanted to go home to New Zealand to be closer to his son who faces challenges with epilepsy. Consequently, he prefers to keep his options open, and that should be respected. Should the Lions Tour go well and the Wallabies look set to be on the road to recovery and on course to launch a potentially successful World Cup campaign when Australia hosts the global showpiece in 2027, then one could well see Schmidt taking a two year extension. As he said in his various press interviews, he and Rugby Australia will cross that bridge when they get to it.

In the interim, what Australia will get is a commitment to detail and one of the sharpest brains in International Rugby in the shape of one of the best process orientated Coaches around. Liked and trusted by players and fans, Schmidt will bring a much needed injection of stability and order to how the Wallabies are run in the next two years. Long term, his approach may become too much of a straitjacket, as evidenced by Ireland clearly enjoying the freedom to be creative under his successor Andy Farrell, which some say was harder to do under a Schmidt regime. Nevertheless, as a 2-4 year fix to many of the problems the Wallabies find themselves in, both attitude and structure wise, Schmidt is probably the best thing to happen to Wallaby Rugby since John Eales. It will be fascinating to see what he can do with his charges come the Lions Tour next year – but whatever happens from now on, write Australia off at your peril.

One man’s loss but another’s chance to shine?

Marcus Smith contemplates a golden opportunity to stake his claim to England’s 10 jersey, potentially going missing through injury. Will it be tried and tested George Ford who gets to repeat his World Cup heroics or a chance for new boy, Northampton’s Finn Smith to announce himself as a contender?

England Coach Steve Borthwick is plagued by a selection dilemma. Prior to this week, it seemed a nailed on certainty that Harlequins dynamo Marcus Smith would be his first choice fly half. With Smith now injured and set to miss the opener against Italy at a bare minimum, Borthwick’s other two options Sale’s George Ford and Northampton’s Finn Smith are now at the forefront of his selection decisions. Who to pick?

If you ask us, we’d go with Finn Smith for the opener against Italy. It is perhaps England’s easiest game to gamble with and therefore a golden opportunity to give the exceptionally promising youngster a thorough Test of his abilities at this level, prior to the more demanding fixtures which lie in wait as the tournament progresses. Borthwick could then choose to follow that up with what should be a straightforward fixture against a very green Welsh side at Twickenham. After those two opening weekends, if Marcus Smith is back to full fitness then get him on the bench for the Scotland game and allow Ford who proved to be so reliable during the World Cup to start against Scotland at Murrayfield. Depending on how fit Marcus Smith is and how well Ford fares against Scotland then possibly go with a combination of Marcus Smith starting against Ireland with Ford on the bench, leaving that all important final game against France to be determined in terms of your fly half options.

Or conversely if Finn Smith has an absolute stormer against Italy followed up with a demolition of Wales, will it be Marcus Smith and George Ford who are battling it out for bench warming duties for the rest of the tournament? We still think it will be a combination of the above-mentioned scenarios, but there is no denying the quality of Finn Smith and the potential he promises for England’s future. If he and Marcus Smith are developed to their full potential during this World Cup cycle, then England could find themselves in exceptionally rude and seasoned health in the fly half department come Australia in 2027.

It really comes down to what Borthwick wants out of his number 10 for this weekend and the tone he wants to set for England for the rest of the tournament. George Ford is a more capable defensive and tactical fly half, but Finn Smith brings with him some genuine attacking flair and a boot that can be exceptionally reliable in terms of keeping the scoreboard ticking over. Furthermore, the Northampton playmaker has an exceptionally calm head on his shoulders, considering he’s only 21.

This year in the Six Nations England’s chief rivals for the silverware Scotland, France and Ireland can attack from anywhere, and as good as England are defensively their attacking game was only marginally better at the end of the World Cup than at the beginning. England know that they will have to be much more dynamic in attack coupled to their strong defensive platform if they want to build on their World Cup achievements. Ford’s big game experience or Smith’s dynamism – who will Italy have to contend with this Saturday? We can’t wait to find out, but don’t envy the decision Borthwick will have to make.

The match likely to set the tone for the whole tournament is the opener

In this year’s opening game, last year’s Grand Slam champions meet the 2022 Grand Slammers, with both looking to be the front runners for the silverware this year

Let’s face it, for many people, this is the World Cup final that never was. As a result, it is without doubt the most eagerly anticipated Six Nations opener in years. Ireland go into the tournament as the number two side in the world with their hosts for this weekend’s curtain raiser France in a strong 4th. They are hands down the best two sides in Europe, and despite some enforced changes to personnel on both sides, it’s hard to separate the two of them. Friday’s clash in Marseille has the makings of a Six Nations classic, and it’s only the beginning of what should be a fascinating tournament for both sides and their supporters.

Is there a Grand Slam in the making? We think not, but then we said that about both 2022 where France proved us wrong and 2023 where Ireland left us with egg all over our faces. As we mentioned in last week’s piece, there is the potential for a banana skin lying in wait for both these sides, most notably Scotland at Murrayfield for France and England for Ireland at Twickenham. However, that’s a bit too much crystal ball gazing for the moment, so let’s focus on the here and now and Friday’s lineups.

If you look at the front rows, we think it’s impossible to separate the two. Tadgh Furlong hasn’t been his barnstorming best in the last year, but then perhaps neither has Cyril Baille. Peato Mauvaka is just as dynamic at Hooker as Ireland’s superman Dan Sheehan. Perhaps the biggest question is, will Andrew Porter be able to compete with the behemoth that is France’s Uini Atonio in the front row? If he can, we’d argue that Ireland look like gaining some ascendancy come scrum time. Add to that the power that Tadgh Beirne brings at second row alongside spectacular newcomer Joe McCarthy, and all of a sudden, Ireland really start to look the part in the forward exchanges. However, it’s France’s back row that is likely to prove the great equalizer as the two Captains go at it, France’s Gregory Alldritt and Ireland’s Peter O’Mahony. For us whoever gains ascendancy will in part be down to who gains the upper hand at number 8 at the breakdowns and in the loose, making the struggle between France’s Alldritt and Ireland’s Caelan Doris one of the highlights of the afternoon.

In the half backs, it’s the first real examination of what life after Johnny Sexton looks like for Ireland. The legendary fly half who finally called time at the end of the World Cup on one of the greatest careers Irish rugby has ever seen will take some replacing. The man tipped with filling those giant boots is Munster’s Jack Crowley. We like what we’ve seen so far, and like most, do not see the point of trying to draw comparisons with Sexton. Crowley will need to develop his own identity and style, and we sincerely hope the Ireland Coaching staff will enable him to do so. He’ll have his work cut out for him though on Friday night in Marseille against France’s Mathieu Jalibert who has seized with both hands the opportunity afforded him by regular fly half Romain Ntamack’s prolonged absence due to injury. Maxime Lucu is another who is no doubt relishing the fact that he gets to duke it out with Nolann Le Garrec for the scrum half berth this Six Nations, with the latter consigned to bench duty for Friday’s encounter. France may be missing the likes of Dupont and Ntamack in this part of the field, but they still ooze world class quality.

In the backs, it’s a veritable assortment of some of rugby’s finest dancing feet. Perhaps for Ireland, the most interesting battle and one we can’t wait to see is that between Ireland’s Calvin Nash and France’s Yoram Moefana. The Munster winger is a player who has consistently caught our eye in the last year, and we’re delighted to see him finally get a chance to prove himself on one of Test Rugby’s biggest stages. Mofana on the wing is an interesting call as he tends to play more in the centers, and as a result, is this a golden opportunity for a memorable debut from Nash? France’s Jonathan Danty and Ireland’s Bundee Aki are likely to steal a few headlines in the center channels. Has Ireland’s James Lowe really got the pace and defensive skills to keep the most spectacular try machine in Test Rugby right now France’s Damian Penaud in check? Last but not least one of the fastest and most reliable fullbacks in the global game right now, Ireland’s outstanding Hugo Keenan, meets the tactical nous and vision of France’s Thomas Ramos allied to a boot that rarely misses its targets.

In short, what a contest we have on our hands and one we find it almost impossible to call. Either way we expect to be fully entertained for eighty minutes as two of the world’s best sides put their considerable skill sets on show in a contest that from the very outset will lay down the marker for which team will be the one to beat this year. It could be argued that by the time referee Karl Dickson calls full time, the winner will already have one hand on the trophy after only the first game of a Championship that looks set to be one of the most interesting post World Cup Six Nations in years.

England’s Steve Borthwick will want to lay down a marker that his 2nd year in charge is all about building on England’s surprise performance at the World Cup. Meanwhile, Italy’s new man knows he has to turn Italy’s momentum under his predecessor into actual wins, and as a result, Saturday’s opener is critical for both Coaches.

Steve Borthwick will want to turn England’s impressive performance against all the odds at last year’s World Cup into the ability to contest for the silverware this Six Nations. Meanwhile, his host, Italy’s new Coach, Gonzalo Quesada, knows that Italy’s recent competitiveness has to be translated into Six Nations wins

England’s game to lose – maybe? Or Italy’s chance to at last start the tournament on more than just a promising note of competitiveness? Every single game this weekend throws up some fascinating permutations, and Saturday’s dustup in Rome is no exception. England will want to lay down a marker that the promise they showed in last year’s World Cup, ultimately finishing as bronze medalists, was no flash in the pan. Meanwhile, Italy will want to show that all the promise they have shown in the last eighteen months can now start to be translated into results under new Coach Argentinian maestro Gonzalo Quesada.

While many questioned the wisdom of replacing Kieran Crowley as Coach after the last World Cup, given Italy’s blowout in the global showdown, perhaps it was time for change. Also, let’s not forget that Quesada brings with him some serious Coaching pedigree. He boasts an impressive Coaching record in the TOP14, and who can forget that in his one year in charge of Argentinian Super Rugby side the Jaguares, he managed to get them to the final. We can’t wait to see what he can do with Italy, who find themselves in very similar circumstances to the Jaguares back in 2019.

England Coach Steve Borthwick, on the other hand, knows how his charges can rise to the challenge after the World Cup. As a result, it is clear that there is a quiet sense of optimism in the England camp. A recent spate of injuries hasn’t made his selection decisions any easier, but if England can finally get their attack going then they could well be one of the teams in the hunt for glory come the closing stages of the tournament.

For Italy, despite the impressive talents of their Loosehead Prop Danilo Fischetti, they are likely to struggle in the front row and set piece contests. However, if the England second row has one of their off days, Italy could pose the Men in White, some serious problems in the shape of Niccolo Cannone and Frederico Ruzza. Ruzza’s skills in the loose and the lineout are exceptional, while Cannone is a genuine nuisance at the breakdown. It’s a capable back row with Michele Lamaro, the battering ram of Sebastian Negri, and one of the outstanding players of last year’s Six Nations number 8 Lorenzo Cannone. For Italy’s forward pack to fire, they need patience and discipline as well as knowing that miracle plays are just not part of Italy’s DNA yet.

In the halfbacks, we can’t wait to see how Super Mario meets rugby in the shape of the Garbisi brothers, Paolo and Alessandro. Paolo as fly half needs no introduction, but his brother Alessandro has been turning heads in the scrum half berth at Benetton. Tommaso Menoncello is back from injury after missing the World Cup alongside Ignacio Brex in the midfield, and this makes for a very tasty and exciting center pairing. Speedsters Monty Ioane and the exceptional Ange Capuozzo give Italy plenty of power and pace out wide, and if Tommaso Allan has a good day at fullback, then Italy have a capable starting XV if they can keep their composure.

For England, like we’ve already said, we feel that their front row should easily have the measure of Italy, though their second row could face some challenges. In the back row, apart from the phenomenal talents of number 8 Ben Earl, it could be slightly less stable than Italy’s offering particularly with the untested flanker combination of veteran Sam Underhill and new boy Ethan Roots.

After much speculation, Borthwick has gone with George Ford as his starting number 10, but should England pull away early, will we get to see Finn Smith strut his stuff off the bench and really open up the English attack, especially when allied with live wire scrum half Alex Mitchell, his Northampton team mate? Fraser Dingwall finally gets a debut in the centers despite being on the periphery of the England squad since 2019 alongside one of England’s standout players of the World Cup Henry Slade. Tommy Freeman who has been outstanding for Northampton this season gets the nod on the wing alongside Elliot Daly who most English Coaches and fans seem to have a love/hate relationship with, but whose powerful boot takes some beating. At the back, the irrepressible Freddie Steward will look to regain his confidence after a troubled 2023 season, which had as many lows as it did highs, despite his mastery of the aerial battles.

This is a genuinely fascinating contest which, in principle, England should win, but there are absolutely no guarantees. Italy have a habit of opening their campaign in style and at home in front of an always passionate Stadio Olimpico, England will need to negate the crowd from the get-go. However, as impressive as Italy have been composure and patience are not their strongpoints as matches unfold, and as a result in the last quarter their execution goes out the window as they start to chase games and their style of play becomes overly ambitious and a tad desperate. England are masters of the long slow grind and will be more than happy to let the Italians trip over their own bootlaces if they start to panic. Consequently this is a game for England to settle their nerves, start to develop an attacking game in the final quarter if they have a comfortable lead on the scoreboard and ultimately leave Italy with all the work to do.

Gatland rolls the dice against Townsend, who has plenty of reasons to smile

Welsh Coach Warren Gatland has put his faith in the future with perhaps the youngest Six Nations squad Wales has ever seen, while his opponent on Saturday fields perhaps the most settled Scottish Six Nations squad we’ve seen in years

Another intriguing contest awaits us at the Principality Stadium on Saturday in Cardiff. Many feel that Scotland are the favorites for this one, and while we can see the logic behind that, much like the game being played before it in Rome, this match may well have a few twists in its tale before referee Ben O’Keefe blows the final whistle.

Despite Wales Coach Warren Gatland naming a young squad for this Six Nations and one of their youngest ever Captains in second rower Dafydd Jenkins at 21, there is still some serious experience in the starting XV against Scotland. Gareth Davies, Nick Tompkins, Josh Adams, Adam Beard, Ryan Elias, and Aaron Wainwright between them boast almost 300 caps for Wales. Consequently, it’s not exactly lambs to the slaughter as some pundits have described it. Admittedly, we fear that the front row may well struggle against Scotland, particularly if Ryan Elias’ lineout throwing goes wayward as it has a tendency to do. In the second row, Adam Beard should lend some calm to his partner and Captain Dafydd Jenkins, but it’s still a bold gamble by Gatland to hand the youngster the leadership role in what will be a challenging campaign. Meanwhile a solid back row featuring the exceptional talents of Leicester’s Tommy Reffell ably assisted by Aaron Wainwright who has provided some much needed Welsh grunt and grit at times, should help keep Wales honest in the face of a daunting Scottish back row.

It’s that halfback pairing, though, for Wales that really needs to fire. We all know what Gareth Davies can do at scrum half and Sam Costelow has looked like a worthy successor to Dan Biggar at times, but it’s just not a reliable or consistent enough offering when juxtaposed against the havoc and controlled chaos that Scotland’s Finn Russell and Ben White can cause. Wales have no slouches on the wing in the shape of Rio Dyer and Josh Adams, but can Josh Adams keep Scotland’s one man wrecking ball Duhan van der Merwe in check while Kyle Steyn proved to be a revelation for Scotland in last year’s tournament?

However, the most fascinating experiment by both sides will be at fullback. Both Coaches have chosen to field players with one cap between them. Wales Cameron Winnet makes his debut while Kyle Rowe has a mere 1 cap to his name for Scotland. Rowe has been on fire for Glasgow Warriors, though his normal position is on the wing and Scotland Coach Gregor Townsend would have no doubt preferred Blair Kinghorn in the 15 jersey had it not been for a training injury this week. It’s a massive experiment for both sides and one that could prove costly.

Nevertheless, even with it being in the cauldron of the Principality Stadium, it’s hard to argue against Scotland coming across as the more settled and proven side. Admittedly they had a poor World Cup, and will want to atone for it, but we can’t help feeling that their exploits in France were not an accurate reflection of their capabilities and more that of being placed in a rather lopsided draw right from the get go. Scotland are invariably given the Dark Horse tag at the start of every Six Nations, but this year that label appears to have some genuine weight to it, as perhaps more than any other side they know who they are, how they want to play and what they are capable of.

So let the games begin!!!!

The Lineout Calls of the Week

The last weekend of European Champions Cup playoffs is the perfect appetizer for the Six Nations in just over two weeks’ time. While a few of the teams have already qualified for the knockout stages, for the majority of teams, places and pecking orders are still up for grabs. Even for those lucky few who have qualified, there’s the small matter of a strong finish to ensure that they get a home game in the Round of 16. In short, there is EVERYTHING to play for this weekend. The rugby up to now despite the rather clunky format of the Pool stages has been spectacular, and if any of the skills on display make it into the forthcoming Six Nations are we ever in for a treat!

On that note, with the start of the Six Nations only two weeks away, the Coaches have named their squads, and we delve into who looks the business and who looks set to upset the apple carts. As everyone else seems to be talking about it we offer our take on Welsh superstar Louis Rees-Zammit’s shock move to the NFL, and last but definitely not least we raise a toast to the exciting announcement of the first ever British and Irish Lions Women’s tour to New Zealand, as yet another affirmation of the rapid upwards trajectory of the Women’s game.

In short, there was plenty to keep our pints frothy this week, so let’s dive into it!

Champions Cup Knockout Race – it doesn’t get much more nerve-racking than this!

Despite some of its weaknesses in terms of structure, this year’s Champions Cup is serving up some truly extraordinary rugby propelling us into an enthralling final weekend of the Pool stages with EVERYTHING to play for for so many teams. As its tagline goes, it’s still the one to win – just ask Munster’s Simon Zebo.

First of all, if you’re like us, you will have been amazed at some of the rugby that has been played out over the first three rounds of the Pool stages in the Champions Cup. In short, it’s been high octane extraordinary entertainment. While a few teams head into this weekend knowing they have secured a berth already in the knockout round of sixteen, there is still plenty to play for across the board, especially to determine who gets home fixtures in the Knockout stages. There is only one team so far that is completely out of the running and that is Stade Francais (surprising given their form in the TOP14) but for a host of other teams there is everything to play for this weekend.

In Pool 1, Bordeaux and Lyon have already qualified, but Bordeaux will want a strong finish on the road to guarantee them a home game in the first of the knockout stages. No easy task when you consider they have to make the long trek to the cauldron of Loftus Versfeld in Pretoria and the added challenge of playing at altitude after the long journey. The Bulls look the best placed team out of Pool 1 to take one of the remaining knockout spots still up for grabs, especially given the fact they are likely to field a full strength side on their hallowed home ground backed by their fanatical supporters. For Lyon, it’s a trip to Saracens, but the English outfit will be rattled after the schooling they received at the hands of Bordeaux last weekend. Meanwhile, Bristol Bears will fancy their chances despite the trip to Galway to take on Connacht. Unlike Saracens and Bristol, Connacht’s chances of making it to the knockouts have become slim at best and require both Bristol and Saracens to slip up massively this weekend.

Pool 2 has been dominated by Bath and Toulouse, who are both through to the knockouts, making this weekend’s fixture between the two a genuine treat. Despite the genius of Bath and Scottish maestro Finn Russell you’d have to put your money on the Frenchmen who are keen to put a record sixth European star on their jersey, especially given the fact that it’s being played in front of the Toulouse faithful at home. However, English outfit Harlequins look the best placed out of the Pool to claim one of the last spots up for grabs as they host a promising Ulster side who have just fallen short of the mark this year. Racing 92 and Cardiff may have something to say about that, but sadly, especially for the Welshmen, it would look increasingly unlikely.

Pool 3 has seen Northampton back to their very best. Northampton have been a traditionally strong force in both the English Premiership and Europe. However, this year, they have been sensational. Qualifying already with seeming ease, all that remains is a tough trip to Munster, where despite a slow start, all the lights seem to have come on just when they are needed most for the Irishmen. However, if Northampton can bring their phenomenal form with them on the road, a home fixture in the Round of 16 is guaranteed. Pool 3 has been dominated so far by English teams with Exeter also showing some of the pedigree that won them the title in 2020. Exeter, despite a road trip this weekend, will be feeling more than a little optimistic about a strong finish to their Pool campaign. They face a Bayonne side for whom Europe has clearly been a bridge too far this season after their promotion to France’s TOP 14. Munster, however, may well have something to say in regards to how the knockout rounds will look, as they have looked particularly strong and midway through both their URC and European seasons have suddenly come alive. Northampton will be a hard side to knock over this weekend, but if anyone can do it, especially on the almost holy ground of Thomond Park, then it’s Munster. Glasgow and Toulon are for all intents and purposes out of the mix though the Scotsmen must surely feel a tad unlucky but there is a chance they could make it as they have had a strong campaign for the most part.

Pool 4 remains relatively wide open, with only Leinster having already secured a spot in the knockout stages. They face a challenging trip to knockout hopefuls Leicester, but a home Round of 16 fixture would appear to be nothing more than a formality for the Irish juggernaut. However, for everyone else, it’s open season. The Stormers have been playing some extraordinary rugby this season and will definitely fancy their chances on the long road trip from Cape Town to Paris to face a Stade Francais side playing for nothing more than pride. However, Leicester Tigers and Sale Sharks are still VERY much in the mix for a strong finish. Leicester’s date with Leinster is a potentially serious fly in the ointment for the English outfit, even if it is a home game at Welford Road. Meanwhile, Sale have the unenviable task of hosting a La Rochelle side that may be coming to the party slightly late but who now look in genuinely ominous form. If we were to place our bets on how the Pool will finish we’d argue La Rochelle second, Leicester 3rd and Sale 4th, however we’re definitely holding onto the receipt for our crystal ball fearing it could end up being a tad defective.

Either way, we’re all in for a genuine festival of high octane rugby this weekend, and you won’t want to miss a second of it!

Six Nations Squads – on paper, these are the three to beat!

After watching French teams in action in the Champions Cup, it’s hard to deny Fabien Galthie’s men the favorites tag, but Andy Farrell’s Ireland may have a lot to say about it while Steve Borthwick’s England hope that their surprise performance at the World Cup and some stellar performances from English clubs in the Champions Cup might help them get into the top three.

Like we said last week, we are really looking forward to the start of this year’s tournament, unlike in past tournaments that have come straight off the back of a World Cup. There are a lot of new faces in the squads, coaching shuffles, and if form in the Champions Cup is anything to go by, we are in for a treat. We hold that France, Ireland, and England are the three taking the first three spots on the grid, but as always, we’ve had massive difficulty placing Scotland in terms of their chances. However, for the purposes of this piece, we’ll go with our gut and stick to the order we’ve settled on after much debate as to who the three front runners may end up being.

France must surely be the side looking most likely to win it. Sure there won’t be Antoine Dupont in the mix or Romain Ntamack, but then just watch a highlights reel of some of the French teams in Europe and all of a sudden that point seems null and void. Perhaps our only concern would be in the prop department, but at Hooker France is stacked with Peato Mauvaka and Julien Marchand set to make life a misery for the other teams. Meanwhile, they have depth in their second and back rows that most Coaches can only dream about. No Antoine Dupont, we hear you say well what about Maxime Lucu and Nolann le Garrec, and it almost seems like a bit of a moot point. The same can be said about the absence of Romain Ntamack with Matthieu Jalibert showing some career defining form at the moment. Their backs set a blistering pace, and the center channels are both sound defensively and lethal in attack. In short, we are struggling to find any deficiencies in this French squad. However, that’s what we said about France’s World Cup ambitions, and look how that turned out.

France this year will be without their traditional home of Stade de France as the venue is off limits due to preparations for Paris hosting the Olympic Games this summer. With both of their games against the other two title contenders, England and Ireland, being at home, the draw has certainly favored France this year. The only potential flies in the ointment are a very difficult trip to Scotland and the visit from Italy which for some reason often tends to catch France napping, though usually only at the start of the competition and this year’s fixture against the Azzurri is mid tournament. Wales should be nothing more than a formality even in the Principality Stadium, leaving le Crunch against England and a possible Grand Slam in the mix in Lyon on the final weekend of the tournament.

Ireland, though, may well have a great deal to say about France’s title ambitions, and the opening game of the tournament between the two may well set the tone for the entire Championship. The big question for Ireland will be what does life without Johnny Sexton look like. It’s going to be a three way race for who gets to wear the ten jersey going forward between Munster’s Jack Crawley and the two Leinster representatives of Ciaran Frawley and Harry Byrne, with the Munsterman clearly taking pole position. There’s a new Captain in the shape of 34 year old Shamrock warrior Peter O’Mahony, and we’re expecting second rower Joe McCarthy to cement his place in Ireland’s future over the coming weeks. In the meantime, expect to see two Ulstermen also make a name for themselves going forward, Number 8 Nick Timoney and Hooker Tom Stewart. There are all the usual suspects in the backs but a player we are really excited to see is Munster winger Calvin Nash, and can Ulster’s Jacob Stockdale return to the form that took the world by storm a few years ago?

Ireland face a challenging schedule, however, and it remains to be seen how this newer looking Ireland fare with the majority of their fixtures being on the road. They start off with a daunting trip to Marseille against France, and their only home fixtures are against the two weakest teams in the competition Italy and Wales. They also have the unenviable task of ending their campaign with two exceptionally tough road trips to Twickenham to face England and then end their tournament at Murrayfield against a Scotland side that will either be the revelation of the Championship at that stage or ending on their traditional damp fizzle. As good as Ireland are, given their schedule, we can’t help feeling that they’ll end up finishing a strong second with a Triple Crown in the bag.

If England’s surprising run through the World Cup finishing as bronze medallists is anything to go by, then they could be the side that everyone writes off at their peril. Furthermore, add into the equation the stunning form of sides like Northampton in the European Champions Cup, and all of a sudden, England look like they pose a genuine threat this year. Coach Steve Borthwick has settled into his role and seems to have the buy-in of his players. In short, this could be a genuinely fun year to be an English supporter after the misery of the last few. If England’s forward pack can gel and keep its discipline then there is the nucleus of a very potent unit there, especially with Borthwick cleaning out his cupboard of players that can no longer make the cut giving room for a younger generation to shine. The same can be said of the backs, and with no Owen Farrell in the mix, is this the year for Marcus Smith to really make the 10 jersey his own?

England start their campaign with a potential banana skin before they have had time to gel, by heading off to face a new look, Italy, under new management in the shape of Gonzalo Quesada. The visit from Wales to Twickenham should consolidate whatever good work gets done in Italy, preparing them for one of their most difficult assignments of recent years, a daunting trip to Murrayfield and their nemesis Scotland. If they emerge smiling from that encounter, then they will fancy their chances against a Johnny Sextonless Ireland at Twickenham before heading off to end their campaign against France in Lyon. Le Crunch match may not be being played at the Stade de France, but the noise generated by the 60,000 crammed into the Stade OL will be intimidating to say the least on the final game of the Championship especially if France are chasing the Grand Slam at that point.

Six Nations Squads looking to ruffle some feathers at the top

Scotland’s Gregor Townsend may have something more celebratory than just coffee in his cup come the end of the Six Nations as once again Scotland look set to spoil everyone’s parties, while Italy hope new Coach Gonzalo Quesada can finally nudge Italy over the hump of underachievement and write Warren Gatland’s Wales off at your peril despite the dismal state of rugby in the Principality

The trio of Scotland, Wales, and Italy may not be silverware contenders this year, but their potential to derail the best laid plans of the other three is a genuine possibility. Having said that, though, we genuinely feel that Scotland could well end up surprising us all and end up being in with a shot at the title this year. That may sound like a broken record, but bear in mind that the Scots made an early exit from the World Cup, and their seasoned veterans may well be the freshest of the top flight stars heading into the tournament.

We had a genuine tussle over where to put Scotland in terms of their chances heading into this Six Nations. Some could say they are definitely in it to win it. However, the issue of a lack of tournament consistency and staying power remains for us Scotland’s genuine Achilles Heel despite some of its seriously world class talent. In short, will this year be any different? Make no mistake, Scotland head into this tournament with some genuine depth across all positions and, for once, are not nursing a casualty list from hell. The talent, skill, and genuine grunt where it is needed is all there this year in Coach Gregor Townsend’s selections. The question simply remains as to whether or not they can go the distance for five rounds. We would like to say that this is the year, but sadly, history has proven us wrong every time. In the interim, however, we can guarantee that Scotland will provide us some of the most memorable games of the tournament as well as throwing the form book out the window. In short, be prepared to be entertained by the Men in Blue.

The tone for how Scotland will do will be set by that trip to Wales on the opening weekend. Put Wales to the sword and follow it up with throwing France off their game at Murrayfield a week later and all of a sudden Scotland could be in it to win it, especially if they manage their now customary win over England in Round 3 also to be held at Murrayfield. It then becomes that classic question of whether or not Scotland can find the formula to finally go the distance for a change. Traditionally, they run out of gas in the final rounds of the Championship, and this year will also not be kind to them in that regard. There is the awkward matter of a trip to Rome, which has often caused them to blow a tire in the past followed up by a final game against Ireland at the Aviva who by that stage could be chasing a Grand Slam in front of a delirious Dublin crowd. We’ll learn a lot about Scotland this Six Nations and what it means for the future and this next World Cup cycle.

Wales may surprise us all, and despite the ongoing crisis of confidence going on in the game at a domestic level, Coach Warren Gatland’s ability to turn the Men in Red into a formidable force that defies domestic form is legendary. He’s gone for one of the youngest squads ever seen in a Welsh Six Nations tournament, and there is no doubt about where his priorities lie – you guessed it Australia and the World Cup in 2027. While he will want to see his side competitive, his and perhaps even many Welsh supporters’ expectations of this tournament will be all about performance and building for the future rather than results. It’s a genuinely exciting Welsh squad that, while it may lack experience, is not short on talent, and the building blocks for the future are there for all to see. If this crop of Welsh youth thrives at Test level, then by the time the 2026 edition of the Six Nations rolls around expect Wales to be very much in the hunt for the silverware regardless of the woes of the domestic game.

The Welsh fixture list is not overly kind to the Men in Red this year, although they do have the advantage of getting their campaign underway at home to a Scottish side that is already causing a stir. However, if their opener doesn’t go well, then a confidence of crisis could set in for Gatland and his young charges as they spend the next two rounds on the road against Ireland and England. They end their campaign in the noisy yet comforting cauldron of the Principality Stadium against France and finish against Italy. However, this final fixture against the Azurri even in Cardiff has often proved to be a giant banana skin for them in recent years and it will be fascinating to see how well this young squad has coped with the pressure by this point.

Last but not least, traditional Wooden Spoon holders Italy look to show that the progress made under former Coach Kieran Crowley in the last two years was no flash in the pan. Under the new management of Argentinian Gonzalo Quesada, Italy look to hopefully turn a corner at long last. We admit that we like everyone else sound like a broken record when it comes to describing Italy at the start of every Six Nations, in our hopes that this year is the year that Italy finally silence their critics. Will Italy finally transition from feisty competitors who still manage to clutch the Wooden Spoon after yet another seemingly false dawn into a side that can genuinely compete for a spot in the top three finishers? It’s still a relatively young side, but boasting enough experience to make life difficult for some of the bigger teams. Add into the mix Benetton’s stellar form in the URC where they currently sit second as well as being serious contenders for Challenge Cup silverware this year in Europe, and there is room for cautious optimism if you’ll be sporting an Italian jersey over the coming months.

Nevertheless, they only have two home games this Six Nations, albeit their opener is against England in the Stadio Olimpico in Rome. Catch England napping, and all of a sudden, Italy could build some momentum for an almost impossible trip to Ireland a week later. However, there’s that two week lull in between before a trip to Lille, a venue which may suit Italy against France as the north of the country is not a traditional rugby heartland for Les Bleus – not exactly a neutral venue but also not the deafening cauldron of the Stade de France. They then return home to face a Scottish side who at that stage will either be a) waiting to unravel in the most spectacular yet depressingly familiar Scottish fashion or b) dismantling everyone who had the cheek to cast doubt on their Six Nations aspirations. Finally it’s off to Cardiff for a fixture that Italy often seem to relish at the end of the Six Nations – a surprise attack on Wales to salvage their campaign, especially as both these sides could at that stage be debating who will end up clutching this year’s Wooden Spoon.

Louis Rees Zammit – the Welsh speedster aims to seek his fame and fortune across the Pond

While it definitely came as a surprise, the departure of the fastest Welshman alive to the lure of the US Dollar and pursuit of a childhood dream is to be respected and even applauded – we just hope it doesn’t prove to be the dead end it has for so many of his predecessors who have chosen similar journeys

To quote Monty Python – “nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition”, and to be honest that rather sums up our initial reaction to the announcement that all star Welsh winger Louis Ress-Zammit was to turn his back on a stellar International Rugby career and seek his fame and fortune in American Football in the NFL. Put aside our own distaste for the American version of playing with an oval ball – a game that despite its lavish budget (more likely because of it) is interrupted constantly by ad breaks and has about as much momentum as us doing our annual tax returns. Sure we appreciate there are complexities to it, not that we’ve invested the time or energy to try and understand them and that for millions of fans it’s a passion bordering on religion just as rugby is to us. Nevertheless it’s just not our cup of tea or pint of ale as we prefer our sporting pursuits served up in 80 minute bursts of frenetic action as opposed to 3+ hour marathons where the the ball can often only be in play for a mere 11 minutes.

However, clearly, for the young Louis Rees-Zammit and especially his father, the American game has been a fascination since childhood. His father, against all the odds, played the game in the UK, where it must have been a minority sport akin to playing ice hockey in the Maldives. His father was passionate about the game and instilled such passions in his son, who clearly has hankered a dream to give it a go. In that regard, you have to respect Rees-Zammit. The dreams that shape our childhood should as much as possible never be compromised. The Welsh winger also harbored a dream to don the red of his native Wales and also that of the British and Irish Lions. To his credit and through sheer determination and hard work, he has managed to do both and excelled in the process, and been a credit to both jerseys, all by the tender age of 22.

This next adventure of his should be celebrated as an example of someone living out their hopes and dreams. Admittedly, there have been very few successful transitions from rugby to American football, and despite his extraordinary talents, there are absolutely no guarantees that Rees-Zammit will break that mold. He will certainly give it his best shot despite the odds seeming to be against him. Some have said that it’s the lure of money that is driving his ambition, but we find that hard to believe. He was already on the radar for extremely lucrative contracts with several French TOP 14 clubs who would have paid him considerably more than the wages he’ll earn for at least the next two years as part of an NFL team’s practice squad. The vast majority of rugby players who have gone to the NFL have sadly not made it beyond the practice squads and ultimately returned to rugby.

While it may be a huge loss to Welsh rugby in the short term, there is a very strong chance that given the fact that Rees-Zammit is only 22, he’ll be back by the age of 25 if his NFL adventure does not live up to his expectations as it hasn’t for so many who have gone before him. All we say is give the lad a chance to try something he has always wanted to do, and if it doesn’t work out then he knows he still has a home in rugby for at least another five years when he will be at the height of his considerable prowess. Variety is the spice of life, and while it may not be our preferred pathway, we should always salute someone following their dreams. In short best of luck to Louis and we hope that he can rest assured that if it doesn’t work for him, he’ll more than likely be welcomed back by all of us with open arms to the game that has put him on the international sporting radar in the first place.

British and Irish Lions – Women’s Team to make historic first ever tour to New Zealand

The announcement of the first ever Women’s British and Irish Lions Tour to New Zealand in 2027 is a huge cause for celebration and once again serves to highlight the exciting future the Women’s game has ahead of it

We can not begin to describe how excited we are about this. As anyone who has read this blog for a while now knows, Women’s Rugby here at the Lineout is a big deal, and we aim to shout its successes from the rooftops as much as we can. We have found the growth of the Women’s game the most exciting thing that has happened to our beloved game in the last 20 years, and perhaps more than anything is bringing it to a wider global audience. British and Irish Lions Tours have a special place in the pantheon of International Rugby, even though some people now argue that their relevance is an anachronism of the past. A bit like the Six Nations, they are just as much a celebration of the color, camaraderie, and spirit of our game all set against a background of an outstanding spectator and fan atmosphere. In short, they are special occasions for fans and players alike, and given the success of the Women’s game, it is only fair that they become part of the party as well.

The tour kicks off in September 2027 and will see the Lions play against New Zealand’s Black Ferns in three Test matches in addition to a series of warmup games against New Zealand club sides. Given that the next World Cup in England in 2025 is going to boost the popularity of the Women’s game even further, there should be a corresponding positive spin off for interest in the Women’s game in the Lions Home Countries and New Zealand. If the series is a success and the final Test ends up being a decider expect numbers in attendance at Auckland’s famous Eden Park to be akin to those seen at Twickenham for last year’s Six Nations match between France and England. All this means greater Television and viewing revenues and a bigger pot available to help continue growing the Women’s game. While Lions Tours traditionally involve little input from World Rugby, this initial tour may require some support from the sport’s governing body to help alleviate some of the costs that will need to be shouldered by New Zealand Rugby to make it happen and kickstart the process for the future.

While the mechanics of it all, including finance still need some finessing, at the end of the day this is a glorious opportunity not just for New Zealand and the four British Isles Women’s sides the Lions represent, but for World Rugby as a whole as our sport continues to become more inclusive and increases its appeal to ever larger audiences.

Well, that’s it for this week, folks. Here’s a clip of the upcoming Netflix documentary series on the Six Nations to whet our appetites before the tournament begins. It airs on January 26th in a similar vein to the “Drive to Survive” series that they do for Formula 1. Take care everyone and enjoy what should be a thriller of a weekend Champions Cup wise.

The Lineout Calls of the Week – The Things We’re Looking Forward to the Most in 2024

There are so many things to look forward to – where do we begin? In the past, the year following a World Cup has often tended to be a bit of a damp squib in rugby terms. However, we have a hunch that 2024 is definitely going to break that mold. We all have our personal preferences, but this year, International Rugby should continue to shine and pick up on the momentum created by the World Cup.

We’re already seeing it in a Champions Cup that barring some disgruntlement about selection decisions by certain teams is setting us up for what should be a truly stellar set of knockout rounds. The end of the Pool stages in that competition nicely segues us into the first proper dosage of International Test Rugby with the kickoff of the Six Nations in February. That’s followed by our first glimpse of what should be a truly riveting year in International Women’s Rugby as the Women’s Six Nations gets underway, followed by the Pacific Four series and culminating in the WXV.

Then there’s the fascinating and potentially last of its kind tour by Ireland of South Africa in the summer. With the new World Rugby enforced International Calendar set to be part of the Test Rugby landscape from 2025 onwards, traditional summer and fall tours are likely to become a relic of the past with the exception of Lions Tours. Consequently a chance to see South Africa as World Champions host one of the World’s best sides in the shape of Ireland and all their travelling supporters will be a treat to savor before the dawn of World Rugby’s supposedly bright new future. Then to finish off the summer we have the mouthwatering prospect of two reenactments of the World Cup final to be played in South Africa as the Springboks host the All Blacks in two back to back matches as part of this year’s Rugby Championship.

If you’re not excited about this, then you may want to check your rugby pulse, as we and many others certainly are. But let’s delve into why we’re so excited and why our pints are already starting to froth before a whistle has even been blown.

European Champions Cup – things are going to get spicy

While Leinster, Bordeaux, Toulouse, and Northampton are all very much in the hunt for European Glory this year, there are at least 6 other teams hot on their heels with the same ambition

The action that kicks off this weekend in the last two rounds of the Pool stages in the Champions Cup is going to be a fascinating precursor to the Six Nations next month. The continued frisson of two South African teams in the mix adds increased interest to the whole adventure, and despite its ongoing clunky format, it has provided us with some mesmerising matches in the opening two rounds, with the final two weekends of Pool play suddenly very high stakes affairs for many of the teams.

For French interests, there have certainly been some surprises. Prior to the tournament, we’d tipped Racing 92 and La Rochelle to be the teams to beat from a French perspective. Racing 92 are dominating the TOP 14, and we thought it would be a natural progression to translate that form into Champions Cup success. However, it would seem that domestic form and European form, at least in the case of Racing 92, are chalk and cheese. The Parisians, even with the addition of Springbok superstar and World Cup winning Captain Siya Kolisi, have genuinely struggled in the opening two rounds and now have the unenviable task of travelling to Bath to take on an English outfit that just gets better and better. Meanwhile defending Champions La Rochelle have struggled to really make an impact and their decidedly middle of the road form in the TOP 14 shows no sign of abating in the Champions Cup with a tough visit from this year’s English surprise package Leicester lying in wait this weekend.

However, all is not lost for French fans as Bordeaux, now boasting the extraordinary talents of winger extraordinaire Damian Penaud, look to translate their rampaging form in the TOP 14 into European success, and should feel more than a little optimistic about advancing their cause this weekend when they host English outfit Saracens. All bets are on that the men from the Southwest of France are going to go deep into this tournament. Meanwhile, Toulouse are continuing to find their feet in both the TOP 14 and with it the right to assert their impeccable European Champions Cup credentials. The most successful French team in the history of European club competition face a daunting trip to Belfast to take on an Ulster outfit that is rather competitive, to say the least. Nevertheless, expect a late and ominous charge from both these French outfits over the next two weekends.

Meanwhile, it’s English sides that are turning the most heads in the competition so far. Despite all the uncertainties swirling around the English Premiership, it certainly hasn’t hindered a few of its clubs’ European aspirations. Bath are so far proving to be the handful we expected them to be guided by the wily boot and mind of their leading playmaker and Scottish maestro Finn Russell. They should have a comfortable home win over a struggling Racing 92 this weekend, but their final round is a very daunting trip to Toulouse. However, it’s Northampton who have so far taken everyone by storm, knocking off both Glasgow and Toulon. All they have in their way to prevent them winning their Pool is a relatively straightforward home fixture against Bayonne, and then a trip to Thomond Park to deal with a Munster side who by that stage may be completely out of the running for European glory anyway.

While Northampton and Bath may be the English front runners, Exeter and Leicester are keen to make the point that they are very much in the mix as well. Both teams sit second in each of their groups. However, the road to the knockouts is much more daunting for the Men from England’s Midlands. This weekend’s round sees Leicester with the unenviable task of a trip to defending champions La Rochelle. Although the Frenchmen are nowhere near the form they showed last year in either the TOP 14 or the Champions Cup, the thought of them getting knocked out of the hunt this weekend on home ground is something they will not entertain lightly. Leicester have to follow that up with entertaining European and Irish superstars Leinster, admittedly on their hallowed home ground of Welford Road. Meanwhile, Exeter have a slightly easier route to the knockouts. They will take comfort in the fact that they are the hosts when they meet Glasgow this weekend, and if they stick to form, then a close tussle should go their way. Their final Pool game sees them travel to Paris for a date with Stade Francais. This will be no pushover as although the Frenchmen are struggling to register a pulse so far in Europe, in the TOP 14, they are serious title contenders. Could a late run of form by the Frenchmen derail Exeter’s hopes? Either way, these four games could prove to be some of the most enthralling of the entire Pool stages.

In Ireland, we have to confess to being more than a little perplexed, as so far there are only two sides in it, Leinster and Ulster. Connacht are so far nowhere to be seen while a run of injuries is seriously hampering Munster’s campaign and their remaining fixtures look more than a little daunting. Nevertheless, Irish interests will, as they always are, be strongly represented deep into the campaign by the Leinster juggernaut. Leinster are comfortably at the top of the log in the URC and have so far looked the business in Europe. Their remaining Pool fixtures are relatively lightweight with a home game against Stade Francais and then a road trip to England to take on tournament hopefuls Leicester. Nevertheless, given their pedigree, this process should be relatively straightforward. For Ulster, however, the process is not so simple. First up is a visit from European giants Toulouse this weekend followed by a difficult road trip to Twickenham’s Stoop to take on Harlequins, with the Englishmen also very much still in the hunt for one of those last knockout spots.

We also have the sole representatives from Scotland and Wales, Glasgow and Cardiff. While Cardiff’s chances look done and dusted their truly remarkable fight against one of the tournament favourites last month, Bath should and could give their ardent supporters a glimmer of hope. Given the fact they face Harlequins at home this weekend and a struggling Racing 92 in Paris in the final round, is there an outside chance that Wales may have a representative in the knockout rounds of European rugby? Unlikely but not impossible. As for Glasgow while they may look the business in the URC their European form is fair to middling at best, and with two extremely tough fixtures left against Exeter and Toulon, we fear that Europe may be a bridge too far for the Scotsmen this year.

If your interests lie with the two newest kids on the block the South African outfits, the Stormers and the Bulls, then you may be feeling just a little uncertain this year. However, so far, if any of these two teams are going to make it through to the knockouts, then the Bulls would appear to be at the front of the queue. Despite their last game on the road being a loss to Lyon, it was only by one point, and they gave Saracens a fairly uncomfortable lesson in Pretoria at the beginning of the Championship. Given their form against Lyon on the road, we fancy their chances on this weekend’s road trip to Bristol, followed up a tough home game back on the Highveld against French hotshots Bordeaux. The Stormers have not quite had the start to their campaign they would have liked. They struggled in their opener away to Leicester but did manage a home win over defending Champions La Rochelle. This weekend, sees them hosting English outfit Sale Sharks, a match which they should win on their home turf followed up by a trip to Paris and a struggling Stade Francais. The Stormers may be starting late out of the blocks but could finish strongly with a potentially easier route to one of those last knockout spots than the Bulls. Either way, it should make for some exciting late drama from a South African perspective.

Also, while we’re on the topic of European competition, we strongly recommend if you have a FLO Rugby subscription catching Georgia’s Black Lions‘ exploits in the Challenge Cup. The Georgian outfit is on fire after thumping the Scarlets at Parc Y Scarlets and giving Gloucester the fright of their lives in Tbilisi. Their remaining two games against Castres in France and then a rapturous return to the Georgian Capital to face Clermont will be daunting propositions, but the crowd scenes in Tbilisi if the Black Lions pulls off the unthinkable will be worth the cost of your FLO subscription for the month and then some.

So, like we say, this tournament looks set to be a very spicy yet tasty affair indeed and definitely one of our highlights of 2024. We’d argue it’s the best club rugby competition in the world, especially now that Super Rugby is for all intents and purposes simply an exhibition league for New Zealand teams with some scintillating cameos from the Fijian Drua.

The Freshest Post World Cup Six Nations in Years

With a raft of retirements of some of the big names, while others decide to sit this one out, this could be the Six Nations tournament where a plethora of new talent gets the chance to shine straight out of the starting blocks of a new World Cup cycle, and hopefully give us one of the most open and fascinating tournaments in years.

We’ll be honest we usually don’t get all that excited about the Six Nations in a post World Cup year. Players who have been playing Test rugby flat out for a year usually arrive at the tournament exhausted and well off the pace. Despite the history, color, and tradition the tournament is steeped in, it often tends to be a slightly lackluster affair. Well, not so this year, we think.

First of all, there are a raft of retirements across the board of some of the biggest names of the decade. Ireland’s Johnny Sexton, Wales’ Alun Wyn Jones, Dan Biggar, and Justin Tipuric have all hung up their Test boots for good along with Scotland’s Stuart Hogg. Some players have decided to sit this one out, most notably France’s Antoine Dupont and England’s Owen Farrell, and injury clouds hang over a raft of other big names across the Six Nations player roster. There has been a Coaching change in Italy as well as a shuffling of the back room staff in a number of the participating countries.

Add into the mix a large group of new young players who didn’t go to the World Cup and are not suffering from that 12 month Test exhaustion factor, but are rapidly making a name for themselves in domestic and European competition. What you are likely to see are some of the youngest and freshest looking Six Nations squads we’ve seen in years. In short, it’s heady stuff and a golden opportunity for new talent to lay down some markers in this opening round of the next World Cup building cycle. We can’t wait and have a hunch it could be one of the most open and exciting Six Nations we’ve seen in years.

International Women’s Rugby – nonstop rugby excitement for 2024

Women’s International Rugby is going to be a roller coaster ride of thrills and spills in 2024 as it builds towards the apex of the World Cup in 2025

We hate to use the term product when it comes to sport, but there is no denying that Women’s’ Rugby is one that is on an almost meteoric upward trajectory and we couldn’t be more thrilled. Ever since the World Cup at the end of 2022 in New Zealand, the Women’s game has grown exponentially in both terms of popularity and viewership and with it the finances to back and grow it. Record attendances keep getting broken, most notably the 58,498 spectators who poured into the grounds at Twickenham in April to watch an epic tussle between France and England for Six Nations glory, which the Red Roses edged in an absolute thriller. In short, Women’s Rugby is a rip-roaring success, and 2024 looks set to take it to another level.

There is so much to look forward to this year in Womens’ Rugby, and perhaps, best of all, so much of it is now receiving mainstream media and television coverage, even here in Canada. Hot on the heels of this year’s Men’s’ Six Nations the Women’s’ Edition kicks off on March 23rd for five weekends of furious action. Then come the end of June/July, it’s Pacific Four tournament time as Canada, the USA, New Zealand, and Australia face off, with one of the two Southern Hemisphere countries being the host. After that, it’s the return of the WXV at a venue yet to be determined. Last year, it was held in New Zealand, but how exciting would it be if it was held in Canada this year?

Women’s’ Rugby has developed a style all of its own in the last four years, and we liken it to a thrilling hybrid of sevens and 15s rugby which brings the relative strengths of both codes together in one exciting format . In short, we simply can’t get enough and with the added bonus that our own fabulous Canadian women still remain the fourth best team in the World by quite a margin to their nearest rivals Australia makes it even better. Furthermore, Canada remains only one point behind third placed France. The gap is closing rapidly and we’re hugely excited about what Sophie de Goede and her charges can do in the red jersey this year in preparation for what should be the most competitive Women’s’ World Cup in history in England next year.

Ireland’s Tour to South Africa – Rematch anyone?

Just a few scores to be settled here, nothing more……???

After that monster clash in Paris in the Pool stages of the World Cup, it would be a bit of an understatement to say that South Africa and Ireland have some unfinished business, and what better opportunity to settle it than a two Test tour in South Africa in July. There will be other summer tours of note, such as Wales’ trip to Australia and England’s trip to the Land of the Long White Cloud, but none are as eagerly anticipated as the rematches taking place between Ireland and South Africa in Pretoria and Durban this July.

It will also be a good preparation for next year’s British and Irish Lions Coach, Ireland’s own Andy Farrell, who will be taking a sabbatical from his Irish duties starting in December this year till August 2025 to take charge of the Coaching duties for next year’s Lions tour to Australia.

The tour although short, will pose a myriad of challenges for Ireland, as in the space of a week they will have to adjust from playing rugby with all its physical and ball handling effects at altitude on the Highveld to the humid and slippery environment of a game by the Indian Ocean. The kicking and handling game you play in Pretoria is not the same game that will work for you in Durban. Farrell’s Ireland will need to be two different beasts while at the same time trying to figure out what box of tricks Springbok Coach Rassie Erasmus is likely to pull out of his seemingly bottomless hat.

In short, a quick and fascinating tour that will tell us much about the current number one and two sides in the World and where they are headed.

South Africa/New Zealand Rugby Championship Games – The Perfect mix of Grudge and Pride

The Giants will Roar in September and the Rugby World will shake

Put aside all the talk about South Africa potentially joining the Six Nations at some point in the future, as for both these teams, these two annual fixtures loom larger in their national psyches than any others. South Africa and New Zealand regard matches against other nations as important stepping stones to world dominance, but ultimately measure the mettle of how good they really are on who emerges with the bragging rights when the Springboks meet the All Blacks. The mythology around these fixtures is as large as any Six Nations game, and the buildup will start in pubs and bars weeks in advance.

This year, we will see the resumption of the mini tour format used in the Rugby Championship, and it’s the Springboks who end up on the right side of the draw this year. New Zealand will need to make the long trek to South Africa for two back to back Tests in one of the hardest places to tour on the planet. The local crowds will be keen for their heroes to repeat their World Cup heroics as well as that memorable thrashing of their Kiwi foes at Twickenham last year. Ellis Park in Johannesburg and Cape Town will be the venues and expect both to be packed to the rafters. It will be loud, raucous, and just a little bit intimidating, to say the least, for both the All Blacks and their brave band of traveling supporters. Rassie Erasmus will be the man in the Coaching Box hot seat once more for the Springboks and expect the sparks to fly.

However, as daunting as all of this will be for New Zealand, fortune will certainly favor the bold. South African players will have been playing rugby almost nonstop, unlike their New Zealand counterparts, as the one negative by product of what is now an essentially twelve month season given South African clubs participation in European competition since leaving Super Rugby. New Zealand players are likely to be coming into this a lot fresher as well as like their Northern counterparts boasting plenty of new talent. Nevertheless, probably the biggest talking point of all will be new All Black Coach Scott “Razor” Robertson’s first big test of character against New Zealand’s most important rival.

It’s the Rugby Championship, but these two matches will undoubtedly be its biggest highlights. With ongoing Coaching uncertainty in Australia and similar issues in Argentina, the likelihood of these two countries posing much of a challenge with the possible exception of the Pumas at home is slim at this stage. In the case of the Wallabies, it may be heightened if Australian sides are once more put to the sword by their Kiwi counterparts and rising stars like Fijian Drua during the forthcoming Super Rugby season.

Anyway, to wrap things up, you get the gist of where we are going with this. What a fascinating and potentially exciting year we have ahead of us. So get out your Rugby calendars, book your time off, make the necessary excuses to family and friends and hunker down for what should be one of the best post World Cup years we’ve seen in a very long time. Stay safe, everyone, and Happy New Year!

The Lineout Calls of the Week

We start this week’s piece with a heavy heart as we belatedly mourn the passing of a Canadian Rugby Icon, Toronto Arrows’ founder Bill Webb. Bill passed away at the end of August, and we deeply regret that it has taken us this long to get around to paying our tribute to such a noble servant of rugby in this country. Sadly we got caught up in the World Cup fervor at the beginning of September, and it is only now that we’ve finally had a chance to reflect on the legacy Bill leaves behind, and in doing so attempt to pay him a fitting tribute. Along with the sad news regarding Bill Webb, imagine our further grief when we learned last week that his cherished project the only Canadian franchise in the MLR, his beloved Toronto Arrows, is also shutting up shop. In short, for the Men’s game in this country, it’s been a brutal year and one that will be hard to recover from.

We also look at the decision by England Captain Owen Farrell to step away from International Rugby for an indefinite period. In large part this difficult call is a direct result of him finding himself and his family continually in the crosshairs of social media abuse, and even from English fans themselves and other countries in the stands at Test matches. We’ve already lamented the abuse directed at officials and are equally appalled when players and their families also become the targets of such cowardly behavior. It’s a growing problem in our game and must be stamped out before the rot is allowed to spread.

On a more upbeat note we look at the European Champions Cup which kicked off this weekend, and profile the three front runners along with three teams we think are likely to cause the biggest problems for everyone else, and in doing so provide the most entertainment value for your rugby watching/streaming dollar over the next few months.

Canada loses a rugby visionary as Toronto mourns the passing of one of its finest

Toronto Arrows founder Bill Webb was a legend in his own time and a deeply loved member of the Toronto and Canadian Rugby Community. His passing has left a giant hole in the Canadian Rugby fabric.

We’ll be honest. This has been a really tough piece to write. As mentioned above, like many, we were shocked to hear the news of Bill Webb’s passing at the end of August after a valiant struggle with cancer. We had wanted to write something at the time, but with all the other rugby distractions going on then, notably the start of the World Cup, we felt we would be unable to do one of Canada’s finest the justice he deserved in a rushed piece. Since then, it’s been hard to find a way to put into words a fitting tribute to a larger than life personality who had such a massive impact on the rugby landscape here in Toronto and in Canada as a whole. In short, this was a very sad day for Canadian rugby.

However, let us try and celebrate a remarkable rugby life and one that contributed so much to the growth of the game in this country. We were fortunate to bump into Bill on numerous occasions, either pitchside at Arrows games or at Hemingways in Toronto as he and other Arrows personalities sought to build a following for his beloved team. To say that Bill was an enthusiastic and devoted supporter of rugby in not only his native Toronto but Canada as a whole is barely scratching the surface of his commitment to the sport in this country. Always jovial and positive no matter how difficult things may have been for either his Arrows team or Canadian Men’s Rugby in general, it was always a pleasure to have a chat with Bill and his enthusiasm was infectious. Numerous Arrows players have cited how supportive Bill was of the team no matter where the team stood in the MLR standings, especially during last year’s exceptionally difficult season, where the team finished bottom of the league and only managed one win.

Bill started playing rugby in Grade 9 and went on to Captain the Laurier University team in his college days. From there, his larger than life personality was further developed as he spent time studying and playing rugby in England and then traveled extensively through Europe and Asia. He spent a great deal of time in Tibet and Nepal, where he even spent time as a trekking guide and was briefly detained by the Chinese authorities for a few days as a suspected spy. Such experiences would serve him well in a highly successful business career on his return to Canada.

His love of rugby and the values it holds dear served as a beacon for Bill and provided him the motivation to ceaselessly promote the game here in Canada and especially in Toronto. He was, and remained until his death, a key advisor to the Toronto Inner City Rugby Foundation (TIRF) which seeks to build community through rugby in 31 of Toronto’s underserved, low-income and priority neighbourhoods. He was also instrumental in securing funding for the Al Charron National Training Center for Rugby Canada in Langford, BC. A compassionate and loyal servant of the game, Bill felt that rugby could play a vital role in strengthening communities, especially those where young people found it hard to develop a sense of self-worth and esteem. The TIRF programme has been hugely successful in that regard here in Toronto, but most important of all ask any of its players what they feel it has done for them in life and you can see that Bill’s legacy will live on long into the future.

Bill’s tireless drive to establish the first professional rugby team in Canada, his beloved Toronto Arrows, who played five seasons in the MLR, is well documented. It was his heartfelt wish that the team should continue on after his passing, and as a result, imagine our dismay on hearing the news that, at least for now, the Arrows have shut up shop. It is our sincere hope that Bill’s wish that the team remains a part of the MLR can somehow be honored even if the team will play no part in the forthcoming 2024 season. Bill was a permanent fixture on the sidelines of every home game here in Toronto, and no matter what the scoreboard said, his commitment to and support of his players and their fans was 110%.

In short, you can never replace larger than life figures like Bill Webb. The best you can do is ensure that their legacy is honored and built upon. Bill’s tireless enthusiasm and commitment to rugby and its values is something all of us can take forward and promote in our own communities and in doing so hopefully do our part in honoring a remarkable Canadian rugby legend. From all of us here at the Lineout, our sincere and heartfelt condolences go out to Bill’s wife Agnes and his two sons James and Stephen. Bill was one of Canada’s finest, and although he may have hung up his own boots for good, his spirit will tie the bootlaces for many generations to come in this country.

Canada’s only foray into professional rugby comes to an end…..at least for now

Canada’s only professional rugby team, the Toronto Arrows is no more, at least for the 2024 season, and serves to highlight the troubled state of affairs in the Men’s game in this country with Rugby Canada nowhere to be found

Last week’s news that the Toronto Arrows will not compete in next year’s 2024 Major League Rugby (MLR) season was not the start to the New Year we had hoped for. Toronto do not appear to be alone, as North American professional rugby seems in rather troubled waters. Toronto was the second team to fold for the 2024 season, as Rugby Atlanta had also sold up shop, although in their case, they simply relocated to Los Angeles. However, this past week, we also saw the collapse of 2022 MLR champions the New York Ironworkers. In short, the competition is not really producing results, and now the lack of any Canadian teams in the League is a bitter blow.

There are large numbers of Canadian players on many of the teams in the MLR, but somehow unlike other competitions such as Super Rugby Americas in South America, it’s not really making the USA or Canada that much more competitive on the International stage. Three national teams from the South American version of the MLR competition featured in this year’s World Cup, Argentina, Chile, and Uruguay as opposed to Canada and the USA, the sole MLR countries not even qualifying. The MLR’s Glendale Raptors will participate in the Super Rugby Americas competition for 2024 which may help in the USA’s development, but it is still slim pickings and Canada remains lost out in the wilderness of professional rugby.

Rugby in North America is a very hard sell, especially North of the 49th parallel. You can essentially only play the game on the West Coast of Canada as the weather on the East Coast simply doesn’t allow for suitable playing conditions in the first two months of a regular MLR season, February and March. Add to that Rugby attempting to compete with other sports such as American Football and Ice Hockey which have absolutely mind bending advertising and TV coverage revenues and as a result sky high budget ceilings attracting a veritable waiting list of investors. There have been some brave and committed investors such as the Toronto Arrows Bill Webb in rugby in this country, but in general, Rugby is simply not a good bang for investors’ bucks in North America.

Elsewhere in the world the pinnacle of professional sport is ultimately to represent your country, which means that even in South America where soccer is the absolute king, the passion for the national jersey in any sport is so strong and such an end goal for players that you can still bring in the punters. Just watch the outpouring of national pride for the Chileans first World Cup outing this year, with even the President giving them a national send-off. We very much doubt Justin Trudeau or Joe Biden would send Canada or the USA off to the World Cup from Sussex Drive or the White House on national television. Unfortunately, in the sports that dominate the North American landscape, the pinnacle of a football player’s career is the Super Bowl, the Stanley Cup for hockey players, and the World Series for baseball players. In short, these are not international competitions. In Rugby while club passions produce some of the greatest rivalries in the sport, just watch a Munster/Leinster clash if you don’t believe us, the ultimate goal of donning your national jersey is front and center in every aspiring rugby player’s goals.

While we don’t doubt that is also the case for any player in the MLR, be they Canadian or American, their dreams simply won’t attract the funding that by comparison a young player at Toulouse or Leinster’s would. South American players are starting to make such a name for themselves, talent scouts from the three big European club competitions, England’s Premiership, France’s Top 14 and the United Rugby Championship are regular visitors to South American club games. Just witness the raft of signings of Chilean and Uruguayan players to European clubs post the World Cup.

Consequently, the demise of the Toronto Arrows is of concern to Canada’s Mens Program, and we find it slightly concerning that Rugby Canada has had very little to say about it. While it may have been difficult to keep a team going in Toronto, particularly with the sad passing of Bill Webb their primary supporter, efforts should have been made to find investors who may have been interested in relocating the team to a more logical base such as Vancouver or Vancouver Island. Surely Rugby Canada from their cozy offices on Vancouver Island must have connections to some of the considerable wealth and potential investors that are present in Vancouver and its surroundings?

Without a team in the MLR, Men’s Rugby in this country will continue to be very much a fringe sport, and its players denied the exposure they need to be competitive internationally. While the Women’s program has been a spectacular success with Canadian Women players getting lucrative professional contracts in England and France, the same cannot be said for the Men’s program. Canadian Women have been as successful as they are on the international stage precisely because many of them play their rugby professionally in Europe week in week out alongside some of the best players in the world. By comparison, our Men have no such outlet, and with the ongoing problems faced by the MLR, we’re just not sure where they are going to get it. Sadly, there are few Canadian Men’s players, or even US players, who would attract the attention of the cheque signers from the English Premiership, TOP 14 or URC.

The MLR is their best bet for the moment, but with no Canadian teams anymore, and the ongoing woes of the other teams in the league South of the border, both financially as well as very limited success in attracting a sustainable fan base, the future sadly does not look bright for Men’s Rugby in this country or in the US. With the USA set to host the World Cup in 2031, urgent action is needed with both Rugby USA and Rugby Canada needing to come together to make the MLR a meaningful competition as a path to international success. It’s a tall order, but certainly, in the case of the Toronto Arrows, it would be a fitting tribute to Bill Webb if Rugby Canada at least attempted to answer the call.

A player who always put his country first, has made the hard decision to step away to put his family first

England Captain Owen Farrell announced his decision this week to step away from Test Rugby for an indefinite period in order to ensure that he and his family are no longer subjected to abuse, particularly through social media. That he has had to do so is a sad reflection on the state of affairs in our game.

We were very saddened to hear the announcement from Owen Farrell that he has decided to take a step back from International Rugby for his own and his family’s well-being and mental health. As a result, the England Captain will not participate in the 2024 Six Nations, though hopefully we will see his return come the Autumn or England’s Tour to New Zealand in the summer of 2024. The abuse in social media of Owen Farrell has been off the charts this year and is completely unacceptable, and further highlights the blight currently affecting our beloved game, where individuals feel that they can intimidate players, coaches, officials and even their families from the comfort and anonymity of their keyboards.

Hang on, we hear you say you haven’t been exactly kind to Mr. Farrell, at times yourselves, so isn’t that the kettle calling the pot black? Agreed, it’s a fair cop, but we think there is a difference. While Owen Farrell may not be our favourite player at times on the pitch, whether it be for his problematic tackle technique or his outbursts towards officials in the heat of the moment, we have always held him in respect. While he may suffer from a lack of form at times, there is no denying that when he is on song in an England or Saracens jersey, there are few who can touch him. Furthermore, he is one of England’s most experienced players and has helped steer them to some of their greatest moments, and he has also done so in a British and Irish Lions jersey. Whether you personally like the man or not, his contribution to English rugby is immense, and he deserves our respect. We reserve the right to be critical when he or any other player is out of form, but none of it is meant in disrespect, and if it has ever been perceived as such, then we apologise.

However, what concerns us the most is the fact that certain individuals feel that a negative review of a player’s performance in the media then gives them license to target that person and their family in a torrent of highly distasteful abuse whether it be at the pitch or on the internet. There is simply no place for such behaviour in our game, and we’d be hard pressed to call those who do stoop to such levels genuine rugby fans as they simply don’t understand one of the basic principles of the game. We were very saddened to witness at both the World Cup and the Saracens/Bulls game in the Champions Cup this weekend, fans continuously booing Farrell and other players. The Bulls Coach Jake White lamented the behaviour of fans towards Farrell this weekend in Pretoria and hopefully people will get the message so that we can start to put a stop to such loutish and unsportsmanlike behaviour which ultimately tears a huge hole in the fabric of our game.

Let the rot stop forthwith. Owen, rest assured that it is our hope you’ll be back in an England jersey sooner rather than later. Whatever mistakes you may or may not have made in the past and which we may have been critical of, none of them have been made with malice on your part and are more a direct result of you wearing your heart on your sleeve and being the fierce and proud competitor you are for your country and the players you lead into battle. Starting with Farrell, let’s show every Player, Official and Coach the respect they deserve for making our game one of the greatest shows on earth!

It’s the best International Club competition in the World and these three have made it clear that they intend to be the pacesetters

With Bath, Leinster, and Racing 92 dominating their respective domestic competitions, they will be the teams aiming to be Masters of Europe in this year’s Champions Cup, which kicked off this weekend

The Champions Cup came roaring out of the blocks this weekend and left us spellbound and hungry for more. England’s Bath, France’s Racing 92, and Ireland’s Leinster are topping their respective domestic competitions, and this weekend, it was plain to see why. Bath dispatched a spirited Ulster in a match which showed the English outfit in total control, led by Scottish maestro and wizard fly half Finn Russell. Bath have a proud tradition in English rugby, and despite some very lean years recently, they are back to their very best. Meanwhile, in a rematch of last year’s Champions Cup final, Leinster traveled to La Rochelle to take on the defending French Champions. In appalling almost typhoon like conditions Leinster showed a master class of control and discipline which despite a strong challenge from the Frenchmen, saw the Irish outfit finally get to grips with a team that has denied them two successive Champions Cup trophies. Lastly although Racing 92 came just short in Paris against English outfit Harlequins, it was a pulsating contest decided on the finest of margins and showed that the French outfit looks set to only get better with each outing, making a place in the knockout stages an almost near certainty.

Bath’s route to the knockouts is challenging, but you can’t help feeling that they must feel more than a little optimistic about their chances. Their next fixture is a trip to a Cardiff side that got absolutely blitzed by Toulouse. Next up, they have to take on the might of Racing 92, but have the comfort of being able to do it cheered on by the Recreation Ground faithful at home. Their final encounter sees them travel to the South of France to take on European legends Toulouse. However, despite their pedigree, we are not as in awe of Stade Toulousain this year as we normally are. With hopefully some significant form under their belt, by that stage, the English outfit should find themselves in a strong position heading into the knockouts.

Leinster have made the traditional opening statement they always tend to make at the start of the competition. However, this year is a bit different. First up, there was no talisman Johnny Sexton steering the ship at 10. Both his replacements Harry Byrne and Ciaran Frawley rose to the occasion admirably in appalling typhoon like conditions, with the latter taking a monster 60 meter penalty kick which sealed the deal at the end of the game for the Irishmen. What perhaps was most telling was the defensive imprint of World Cup winning Springbok Coach Jacques Nienaber, who has now joined the Leinster Coaching setup. Despite repeated assaults, the Leinster defense was rock solid and was so disruptive to La Rochelle that the French unit struggled to gain any cohesion in attack. However, unlike Leinster sides of the last two years, despite the pressure and appalling conditions, the Irishmen to a man never looked flustered by the task they were handed. There was a calmness under pressure that will serve them exceptionally well in the weeks to come.

They have a difficult game against the current English powerhouse Sale up next, but at least it will be at home. That’s followed by another home fixture against France’s Stade Francais, which should be nothing more than a formality. Their last game before the knockouts is a tough trip to Leicester, but once again much like Bath should they have managed to build up a significant head of form by that stage they should make it easily into the knockouts.

As for Racing 92, we still think they are going to be one of the French teams to beat if not THE French team to beat. Star signing of World Cup winning Captain, South Africa’s Siya Kolisi, is already paying massive dividends as evidenced on Sunday night at Paris’ La Defense Arena. Harlequins were a very tricky proposition, and as mentioned in the next section below, we think are destined to be one of the surprise packages of the tournament. However, Racing took it to them for the full 80 minutes, and some of the line breaks by the French outfit had to be seen to be believed. They kept finding and creating holes in a solid Harlequins defense and were unlucky to not walk away the winners. In short, this is a team that is going to rapidly warm to the task at hand in the coming weeks and has the personnel to do so.

Their fixture list is also rather favorable as they travel to Ulster this weekend, but should have enough to get the job done, followed by a much more challenging trip to Bath. They end by hosting struggling Welsh outfit Cardiff, where the opportunity to claim those all-important maximum bonus points should be a mere formality. Their most daunting fixture prior to the knockouts is that awkward trip to Bath, which would have been so much more comfortable had they emerged the winners on Sunday night. However, with two bonus points from the loss to Harlequins, they should find themselves in a relative position of strength provided things go well against Ulster and Cardiff. They may not have gotten the result they wanted in the opening weekend, but write Racing off at your peril as we remain convinced they are genuine title contenders this year. A side that has been runners up three times must surely finally believe they can at long last end their run of being Championship bridesmaids.

Expect these three Wild Horses to be seriously hard to tame as the Champions Cup starts its stampede across the playing fields of Europe and South Africa

We have a hunch that France’s La Rochelle, England’s Harlequins and South Africa’s Bulls are going to be a rather large hurdle to any team’s aspirations to lift the European Champions Cup trophy in London on May 25th next year.

One are successive defending Champions, another a side whose history speaks volumes about English rugby, and last but not least, the new kids on the block are one of the most feared sides in South African rugby. Looking for troublemakers? Well, look no further than these three.

La Rochelle as back to back defending Champions and boasting a plethora of talent that regularly graces French Coach Fabien Galthie’s selection list will be hard to beat. Although they may have come short against Leinster this weekend at home in Monsoon Mary, it certainly wasn’t for the want of trying. They will be upset that they couldn’t breach a seemingly impenetrable Leinster defence, but they came very close on more than a few occasions, and had the ball not been a giant bar of soap fortune might certainly have favored the brave and in this case La Rochelle. La Rochelle ran at Leinster from every corner of the park and showed some genuine attacking enterprise.

They now face the long trip to Cape Town this Saturday to face the Stormers. However, despite the journey, we fancy their chances. The Stormers have simply not looked all that flash this year, World Cup distractions and absence of key personnel aside, though after their B team’s phenomenal heroics against Leicester this weekend we may have to revise that judgement sooner rather than later. However, it looks to be a perfect sunny day on Saturday in Cape Town, and if La Rochelle play the kind of attacking and kicking game they were able to put on display this Sunday in atrocious conditions, then on a fast dry track they should be more than capable of picking holes in a Stormers defence that looks porous at times. Next up they host Leicester at home and if they’ve had a big win on the road next weekend, they should be able to carry that momentum forward for both Leicester and their final game before the knockouts which is a trip to Sale. La Rochelle do not have an easy schedule as defending Champions in the runup to the knockouts but as they have proven so often this last two years they are more than capable of handling odds that would seem stacked against them.

We had a hunch that Harlequins were going to cause teams some serious bother in this year’s Champions Cup, and after their display in Paris on Sunday against Racing 92, we are now convinced. There are some very big personalities on this team who know how to upset opposition teams’ apple carts. The entire Harlequins front row, including the irrepressible mischief maker and character extraordinaire Joe Marler, caused Racing all kinds of problems on Sunday night. Joe Launchbury looked like he was once more putting his hand up for selection for England in the second row, alongside Dino Lamb, who is a bright prospect for Italy. Alex Dombrandt also seemed to be back to his best at 8, while Danny Care appeared to roll back the years at scrum half. Meanwhile, Marcus Smith made a statement that with Owen Farrell out of the Six Nations, there should be no doubt whatsoever about him sporting the 10 jersey in England’s forthcoming campaign. Andre the Giant smashed everything in his path in the center channels in the best tradition of a rampaging Springbok wing forward.

In short, watch this team as they mean business and appear to have more tricks up their sleeves than their jersey’s trademark emblem. They have a relatively favorable fixture list with no long-distance travel involved. Next up, they face French legends Toulouse at home at the Stoop before traveling across the Severn to face a Cardiff side clearly at sixes and sevens defensively and no match for Marcus Smith’s wily tricks. Their last match is back home at the Stoop against Irish side Ulster. By that stage, the Irishmen will have had a Champions Cup journey from hell having had to face Bath, Racing 92, and Toulouse, which should favor Harlequins rather nicely. Provided Harlequins don’t get complacent, we have absolutely no doubt that we’ll be seeing England’s court jesters in the knockouts.

Last but definitely not least, we have the Bulls, whose demolition of English giants Saracens this weekend at Loftus Versfeld in Pretoria was something to behold. Admittedly, the Englishmen were clearly struggling with the effects of altitude, but the Bulls played a rather dashing and almost uncharacteristic game for them. Bulls teams of old have tended to be all about awe-inspiring physicality and not much else, able to capitalise on the energy sapping demands of playing at altitude on the Highveld. Well, after watching them in action this weekend, we’d say that’s a thing of the past. They ran Saracens off the park in some glorious running and attacking rugby – stodgy and ponderous they definitely were not. If anything one of their traditional assets, the scrum was almost their Achilles Heel. Either way, though, this is a VERY exciting Bulls side to watch who are currently sitting third in the United Rugby Championship.

Admittedly, their schedule leaves a bit to be desired with two back to back trips to challenging opponents. First up, they are off to Lyon in France this weekend to attempt to deal with a TOP 14 side that put on a very impressive away from home display against Bristol Bears. The Bulls are home for Christmas but then it’s the long flight up to England’s West Country to face off against Bristol’s Bears with the Englishmen looking equally enterprising in attack and capable of some physical grunt as the Bulls did this weekend. Their last match before the knockouts, however, is against Bordeaux, who were one of the only two French teams to record a win this weekend and who feature French superstar winger Damian Penaud. However, it’s at Fortress Loftus Versfeld in Pretoria, which should be packed to the rafters if the Bulls go into this game undefeated. Next weekend’s trip to Lyon will tell us more about the Bulls’ fortunes, but we have a strong suspicion that there’s a lot more to write on this story before the knockouts.

So that’s it for this week. Sorry that it has been so long in going to press, but life and work have fumbled us into touch quite a bit since our return from France. Most importantly, we feel genuinely remiss in the fact that it has taken us so long to pay our respects to Bill Webb, and once again, our heartfelt sympathies to his family. In this week’s missive, which has placed so much emphasis on respect, it is only fitting that we start and end with Bill Webb. Missed but never to be forgotten – Rest in Peace Bill and thank you for everything you have done for rugby in Toronto and Canada.

The Lineout Calls of the Week

We have to apologise for still playing catch-up after getting back from France, so unfortunately we’ve had to postpone our review of our outstanding Canadian Women’s performance in the recently concluded Tier 1 competition of the WXV in New Zealand. However, now that we finally get to sit down and mull over what was nothing short of a stellar performance, we have to give our Canadian ladies a HUGE shout out and will start this week’s piece with a focus on their achievements. On a slightly less positive note, we’ll also be looking at the Canadian Men’s initial efforts in the La Vila competition in Spain. We’ll also take a look at the countries that now occupy the top five spots in the World Rankings after the World Cup, and what hitting the reset button will mean for them. Last but definitely not least, we’ll bid a very fond farewell to one of the game’s greatest whistleblowers – the much revered Wayne Barnes.

So without any further ado here’s what kept our pints frothy since our last missive.

Our Canadian Women do us proud yet again!!!!

Canada’s efforts in the recently concluded WXV Tier 1 tournament saw them finish a very strong second ahead of the likes of France and New Zealand, capped off by a fine win against les Bleus.

Canadian Women’s rugby continues to provide us all with hope for the future of rugby in this country as well as being a source of genuine pride. Captain Sophie de Goede and her outstanding charges continue to prove that rugby in Canada is most definitely not a lost cause. Canada’s strong second place finish in the WXV tournament sees them maintain their ranking as the fourth best Womens team in the World, and drawing ever closer to France’s third place ranking.

There is still a considerable gulf between Canada and the best team in the world England, as evidenced by Canada’s only loss in the WXV. However, considering that many of our players are playing their club rugby in many of the same professional teams in England that the Red Roses are drawn from, there is plenty to be optimistic about in terms of Canada’s ability to close the gap in the coming years. For example, England Captain Marlie Packer and Sophie de Goede pack down together in the same scrum week in week out for Saracens. Of Canada’s starting XV against France two weeks ago, the entire forward pack plays professionally in England along with Fly Half Julia Schell, Centre Alex Tessier and Winger Paige Farries – in short almost 75% of the team.

Canada started their WXV with a clinical demolition of Wales, and although the Welsh finished at the bottom of the table, they were not exactly pushovers. They were one of the most competitive teams in the Six Nations this year and ran eventual WXV third place finishers Australia extremely close. Our biggest concern heading into the WXV was that Canada, in reality, had played very little rugby since their World Cup heroics last November. They finished a strong second in this Summer’s three game Pacific Four series against New Zealand, Australia, and the USA. They then had a two game series against England in September, which saw them be competitive, especially in the second fixture, but ultimately fall short on both occasions. Still, only five games heading into the type of high-level competition that the WXV at Tier 1 level is rapidly proving to be left us concerned that they may be slightly short on game time come October.

As evidenced by their solid win over Wales, we shouldn’t have been concerned. Their second game against England which saw them take a relatively heavy loss 45-12, did set some alarm bells ringing given that the following weekend they were set to face France who put them to the sword 36-0 in the World Cup bronze medal final last November. Nevertheless, even in the loss against England, there were plenty of positives, and Canada were very much in contention for the first hour. Sadly, they needed to find another twenty minutes at this level, something we can honestly say they did against France a week later.

What has perhaps impressed us the most about this Canadian Women’s team this year is their ability to learn and learn FAST. All the mistakes they made against New Zealand in the second game of the Pacific Four series they addressed to the full against Australia a week later. The same can be said of the mistakes they made in the game against England in the WXV, when they went on to play France a week later. In short, give this team a to-do checklist, and they go out and tick all the boxes, and do it all in the space of a mere 7 days. The handling was crisper, the set piece work was tighter, and their kicking game much more precise for the most part. Still there were mistakes made and against a powerhouse team like France that is to be expected, but once Canada found their groove on the half hour mark they never looked back and from the 44th minute never relinquished their lead on the scoreboard, despite a very determined comeback from the French. A few opportunities were missed that could have extended the scoreline even further, but Canada kept their composure and made sure that all the pressure was on France and not them.

The win against France and Canada’s strong second place finish in both this year’s Pacific Four series and the WXV Tier 1 are significant milestones in helping them to build on the momentum gained at last year’s World Cup. In both competitions, they faced the best in the world and acquitted themselves well. They may have lost against the number 1 and 2 sides in the World this year, in the shape of England and New Zealand, but in both matches, they gave their opponents serious food for thought. This team knows how to win, and that culture and positivity is evident in everything they do, no matter what the numbers say on the scoreboard – in short this is a team that just refuses to give up.

It’s that commitment and never say die attitude which has so impressed us this past 18 months – qualities the Canadian Men’s Team could do well to emulate. That perhaps makes the case all the more pressing that if the Men and Womens programs are competing for limited amounts of funding, then priority in allocating said funding MUST be merit based. On that basis, the Women’s program must take priority – they’ve earned it and deserve it, plain and simple. We were appalled to learn that some of our Canadian Women had to fundraise themselves to ensure their participation at last year’s World Cup in New Zealand. Meanwhile the Men’s team who can count on one hand the number of games they have won in the last four years, appear to be under no such pressure as a seemingly endless succession of losses and mediocre performances are taken as an acceptable benchmark for maintaining the status quo in Canadian Rugby. If you ask us, that’s a red card all year long!

In short, all this Canadian Women’s team needs to do is find the quality of execution needed to finish out games in the final quarter against outfits like England and New Zealand. They have shown us this year that they can do it against everyone else, there is just that little bit extra that’s required for opponents like the Black Ferns and the Red Roses. Like we say, though, this team’s ability to learn from and correct their mistakes is exemplary, as is their togetherness as a unit and a collective belief in themselves and their abilities. We’ve loved watching them play this year and have been immensely proud of their efforts. We can’t wait to see what they can do in 2024 and feel that come the World Cup in England in 2025, they will be seen as genuine title contenders, but in an even stronger position than they were in the 2022 edition in New Zealand. So well done, Ladies, and we look forward to celebrating with you what should be an even more successful year ahead!

Meanwhile over in Spain……………what can we say?

While the La Vila competition in Spain featuring Canada, the USA, Spain and Brazil seems to be a slightly cobbled together affair in the grand scheme of things, there’s that uncomfortable feeling of “oh dear here we go again” when it comes to Canada

Don’t get us wrong. We genuinely want to sit here and write positive things about Canadian Men’s Rugby. The problem is it’s a bit like being promised a brand new exciting and groundbreaking model of a new car every year only to arrive at the showroom to find that it’s exactly the same as last year’s model, which wasn’t all that interesting to begin with. It’s also perhaps hard to find enthusiasm for a Men’s program that, in comparison to Canada’s extraordinary Womens programme, is a bit like comparing a Ferrari to a Lada. You can get both cars in red, but only one actually has any performance.

Canada’s loss by 42-20 to Spain last weekend in the opening game of the slightly makeshift La Vila tournament in Spain between the USA, Brazil, Canada, and Spain left us feeling more than a little flat. Admittedly, Canada woke up slightly in the second half and played some half decent rugby, but as always with the Mens team, it was far too little too late. What is the point of Coach Kingsley Jones wittering on about positives in the second half when you don’t show up for the first?

Therein lies the problem. Watching Canada shuffle half heartedly around the pitch in the first half with no drive, commitment, or any sense of purpose left a rather bitter taste in our mouths. We simply don’t buy the excuse that Canada hasn’t had much game time this year. While there is some validity to that crutch, Spain hasn’t exactly been pounding the Test pitches this year either. Spain did play five games earlier this year, but only in Rugby Europe (the second tier Six Nations competition) where the only genuine high-level opposition they faced was Portugal and Georgia. They did play Romania as well, but as we witnessed in the World Cup, Romania has been exceptionally poor this year. Canada got to play Tonga twice, which is almost the same. The Spaniards did play Argentina in a World Cup warmup, but that was such a schooling by the South Americans that it almost didn’t count.

As much as we continue to hold the view that the entire Coaching regime under Kingsley Jones needs to be shown the door as soon as possible at the start of this next World Cup building cycle, the players themselves need to take responsibility for Canada’s performances as well. While the Coaching quality may be seriously lacking, the players need to at least show some heart on the pitch. Most of the players looked in the first half as if they’d really rather be somewhere else. At the risk of sounding a lot like Kingsley Jones himself, there were some positives, most notably new number eight Matt Oworu. Unlike many of his colleagues he wore his heart on his sleeve the whole time he was on the pitch, and was one of the few players who genuinely looked like there was a rugby match going on and pride in the jersey actually meant something to him.

While Canada did roll up their sleeves somewhat in the second half and claw back two tries, there is no denying that they never looked like winning that game, especially given the fact that Spain managed to run in a staggering five tries in the first half. Spain, by comparison, looked like they were relishing the task at hand and weren’t afraid to make mistakes and, as a result, were highly entertaining to watch. To be honest, it was a bit like the Ferrari/Lada comparison mentioned above.

There is a strong possibility that Canada will beat Brazil this coming weekend, but let’s be honest, there are no guarantees. However, assuming that they do, what concerns us is that all the failings highlighted in the game against Spain will be swept under the carpet and Jones and his staff will start making bold predictions about the building blocks of a trip to the next World Cup in Australia in 2027. Unfortunately, this will prove nothing. Given the fact that World Rugby, in their misguided wisdom have expanded the competition to 24 teams for Australia, it is now almost guaranteed that no matter how mediocre Canada is, they will qualify. Consequently, a string of wins between now and then against other bottom of the rung Tier 2 nations will give Canada no indication of whether or not the team is actually making any progress to the point where we can once more occupy the top rungs of the Tier 2 ladder – an aspiration that in their present state is nothing more than a pipe dream.

The MLR as North America’s first foray into professional rugby is simply not producing the results at Test level that similar initiatives for Tier Two nations are having in South America and Europe, and we don’t think it’s just a question of money. In North America funding should be much easier to access than in places like Portugal, Spain, Uruguay, and Chile which have miniscule player bases and sporting cultures that are almost overwhelmed by football to the point that there is little if any room for anything else.

In short, we’re tired of the excuses. It can be better than this as our extraordinary women are proving to us every year. It’s time to wake up and smell the coffee burning gentlemen!

So where do the Southern Hemisphere’s big two go from here?

South Africa may be World Champions for a record fourth time, but there is no denying that is the end of an era for this Springbok generation while much the same can be said for some of New Zealand’s class of ’23’.

South Africa have been crowned the most successful World Cup competitor as a result of having now got four Webb Ellis trophies locked away in their cabinet. However, all good things must come to an end, and in their case, this golden generation of the last two World Cups needs a major refit. Legends like Duane Vermeulen have hung up their boots, whilst the likes of Bongi Mbonambi, Eben Etzebeth, Faf de Klerk and Pieter Steph du Toit will all be very much the wrong side of 30 come the next World Cup. Furthermore, and perhaps most importantly, will their inspirational Captain Siya Kolisi still have one more big push left in him at the age of 36 in 2027? We’d argue providing the injury gods are kind to him, probably yes, but it’s clearly a gamble.

South Africa will need some major retooling over the next four years, and while there is talent aplenty in the country, we have a hunch that it’s not quite the caliber of this extraordinary group of Springboks who have risen so spectacularly to the occasion in the last two World Cups. There’s a need for some consistency and Plans A,B, and C in the fly half position. There is no clear succession to Faf de Klerk and Cobus Reinach in the scrum half berth. The United Rugby Championship is rapidly starting to produce an impressive looking set of back and second row understudies to the likes of Etzebeth and Vermeulen, but they need plenty of game time over the next four years. However, their front row stocks still look relatively barren for now and there is ongoing confusion as to what South Africa’s midfield pairings should really look like, whilst the backline in general could use some tweaking with an eye to the future particularly at fullback.

As for New Zealand, they lose some big names after this World Cup most notably in the shape of scrum half Aaron Smith and second rower Sam Whitelock, but we’d argue there is enough new and seasoned talent in this All Black squad that will be the right side of thirty come the next World Cup. Add into the mix a new Coaching regime under the tutelage of the most successful Super Rugby Coach in history, the Crusaders’ Scott Robertson, and All Black supporters have every reason to be wildly optimistic over the next four years. When you consider that back rower and vice Captain Ardie Savea, who was without doubt New Zealand’s best player this tournament will be 34 come the World Cup in Australia and probably at the peak of his remarkable prowess and leadership abilities – it would seem that the All Blacks are in VERY safe hands for the next four years.

The only negative we can see is the continuing stagnation of Super Rugby, despite the addition of Pacific Island sides. The competition is increasingly becoming a very one-sided affair in favor of New Zealand. As a result, New Zealand teams only face genuine competition amongst themselves. We’re not holding our breath that the Australian franchises spread too thinly amongst five sides are likely to become that much more competitive over the next four years. Meanwhile, the odd defeat to sides like the Fijian Drua doesn’t really give New Zealand players enough exposure to different playing styles over the long five month Super Rugby season, before the soon to be revised international calendar gets underway in the second half of New Zealand’s rugby calendar. Juxtapose this against South African and European sides who are exposed to a variety of different styles during the course of the Northern Hemisphere club season in the shape of the Champions and Challenge Cups, along with South African, Irish, Italian, Welsh and Scottish sides all playing together in the United Rugby Championship.

This is not an insurmountable challenge for a country blessed with a depth of talent that most countries can only dream about. As shown during this World Cup there is the nucleus of a very dynamic All Black side in the making over the next four years, but they will need to be mindful of the fact that they are not the International benchmark they have been in years gone by. In many cases, the rest of the World has caught up and, in some cases, surpassed New Zealand. The aura around the All Blacks has gone even if the respect is still there in spades. New Zealand is still a side everyone wants to beat, but this new All Black generation will need to embrace the reality of the fact that they are one of international rugby’s elite rather than its focal point of excellence, if they want to keep us all guessing over the next four years.

In the Northern Hemisphere, it’s time to hit the reset button for Ireland and England, while France simply need to make some design changes

For Ireland despite the pain of yet another quarter final exit the future continues to look bright, France need to attend some classes in decision making and England need to figure out who and what they want to be while developing some desperately needed young talent

After the elation of the World Cup for some lucky nations and the heartbreak for others, one of the most exciting things after the dust has settled is the opportunity to pick up the pieces and in many cases start with a completely clean sheet of paper, as teams start out on their journey of building for the next World Cup. Of the three Northern Hemisphere countries that found themselves in the top five of the World Rankings after this World Cup, Ireland, France and much to everyone’s surprise including perhaps even their own, England there is cause for genuine optimism and excitement as they look to the future.

For Ireland, the obvious heartbreak and emotional scarring of once again not being able to get beyond the Quarter Final stages on their eighth attempt will need to be dealt with. However, we think it’s a bit different this time around. First of all, although they lost to New Zealand, unlike in other World Cups they put on a display that has earned that Quarter Final fixture in Paris the worthy title of one of the greatest games of rugby ever played. In stark contrast to previous World Cups, Ireland did not exit with a whimper come the knockouts, it was a full blooded arm wrestle lost on the finest of margins right to the final whistle.

Some old heads will likely hang up their boots after this World Cup, with talisman and Captain Jonathan Sexton already having called time on an illustrious career. However, there is a raft of exciting Irish talent waiting in the wings ready to take their place. The argument that a lot of younger players didn’t get the game time they needed this previous World Cup cycle is a valid concern, but in the next four years, this can no longer be an excuse. Ireland have to hit the reset button and hit it hard. They are blessed with depth in every position across the park but it now needs to be fast tracked from day one of this new World Cup cycle, and where it is found wanting new recruits brought into the fold in a timely and supportive manner.

Perhaps the biggest question lurking over Ireland is whether or not Coach Andy Farrell will be with the team for the next four years. His contract is up for renewal midway through this World Cup cycle, with him also being tipped for the Head Coaching job for the British and Irish Lions tour to Australia in 2025. This would necessitate him being slightly less hands-on with Ireland for up to a year. Indications would appear to be that the popular Englishman is keen to stay with Ireland till the conclusion of the next World Cup, and we very much hope for their sake that this will indeed be the case.

Farrell has done a brilliant job with Ireland and is very highly respected and liked by his players and the Irish rugby public in general. In short, Ireland will want to keep his services, and he appears enthusiastic about the prospect of his role with the national side being continued. In our humble opinion, the IRFU should be making every effort to iron out Farrell’s contract extension until the end of 2027 as soon as possible. As everyone knows we are very much against the changing of a Coach midway through a World Cup cycle, and if Ireland are serious about breaking their Quarter Final curse, then this uncertainty needs to be put to bed at the start of this World Cup rebuilding phase and not halfway through it. Do that, and despite the pain of October 14th, Ireland’s future still looks very shiny indeed.

For France, October 15th, 2023, is a day that will live in infamy for them, but it needs to be brushed under the carpet of French rugby history as soon as possible. France should have been in at least the semi-finals, had it not been for a lopsided draw, and some poor decision-making at critical moments in the Quarter Final against South Africa. However, give that loss some perspective. They were in that game all the way and only lost by one point. Admittedly, they lost control of the final ten minutes and allowed South Africa as a result to hold on and claw out what seemed an impossible win. Nevertheless, once France are able to move on, the future looks very bright indeed.

This is still one of the youngest groups of players of any of the top nations, blessed with an abundance of truly remarkable talent. Tighten up the decision-making that tripped them up on a few occasions against South Africa in the Quarter Final, and all of a sudden, you have a team that will be exceptionally hard to beat. Remove the added pressure of playing in front of an expectant and demanding home crowd in your own World Cup, and we have a hunch that France will be a lot more relaxed and composed come the World Cup in Australia in four years time. Having been in France for this World Cup, the pressure on Fabien Galthie and his charges to produce that BIG result was palpable to the point where the weight of possible failure must have been almost impossible to bear for this French team at times. France deflated in seconds once Ben O’Keefe blew the final whistle in Paris on October 15th and the country with it. They were still great hosts, but you couldn’t help but feel that despite the disappointment, a massive weight had been lifted off the shoulders of this young but very talented team.

The majority of this French squad who fell just short of the mark this World Cup will be at the absolute height of their rugby prowess come Australia in four years time, with the vast majority of them still being under thirty or just a hair over it. Scrum half Antoine Dupont will only just have turned 32 whilst Fly Half Romain Ntamack will have just turned 28 along with phenomenal number 8 Charles Aldritt, who will have just had his 30th birthday. If they and many of this French team are this good now, just imagine what they are going to be like in four years’ time with that much more experience under their belts. Meanwhile France continue to dominate the World Under 20s championship, the TOP 14 is considered the best club competition in the World, and it’s hard not to feel optimistic about France’s chances come Australia in 2027. We couldn’t help feeling that as good as France looked for this World Cup there was still a year or two more of seasoning required if they really were going to go all the way and lift the Webb Ellis trophy. That will happen in the next four years, and as a result, the rest of the world has been warned!

England was the complete surprise package of the World Cup. So much so that we have a hunch that even they were quite taken aback by how well they ended up doing. Written off by everyone, ourselves included, they exceeded expectations and then some. Did they play a particularly enterprising or attractive brand of rugby? No, but then, in reality, neither did South Africa at times, and they went on and won the thing. England still may have precious little in the way of an attacking game, but when it comes to grunt and determination and perhaps a healthy dose of sheer bloody mindedness, they were hard to beat this World Cup.

They played a shrewd defensive game at times and used their kicking game to make up for what they lacked in attack. The more they played, the more they started to believe in themselves, and by the end of the tournament, they actually looked like they were genuinely enjoying playing rugby again. As they grew into the tournament, they became more expressive and at times even started to look mildly adventurous by their own conservative standards. Owen Farrell, after some initial wobbles, rose once more to the challenge of the Captaincy and, for the most part, led his charges well. Ben Earl finally provided the edge that England has been lacking at number eight for years, while Ollie Chessum provided the added stability and grunt in England’s second row that his partner Maro Itoje has needed for so long.

Questions now remain for England about the future, and answers need to be found quickly. Owen Farrell is unlikely to be around for the next World Cup, and England’s long-term fly half prospect needs to be settled for the next four years. In short, is it Marcus Smith, George Ford, or someone starting to make waves at club level in the Premiership? England can not afford the Jonathan Sexton experiment at fly half as Farrell will be over 36 come the next World Cup. Some hard decisions need to be made here and made soon. The same applies to the scrum half berth with both Danny Care and Ben Youngs now very much out of contention. England also need to determine what they want their midfield to look like, and Manu Tuilagi is not the answer going forward, whereas the likes of Ollie Lawrence and Joe Marchant, amongst others, are. The front row definitely needs some work, but the back row and second rows are finally starting to hum.

If Coach Steve Borthwick can put all the pieces together in the next four years, and allow England to win by playing attractive attacking rugby in conjunction with their ability to win ugly when they need to and which they have proven rather adept at, then this could be a formidable England team in the making. Despite all the criticisms levelled at him after he took over from the universally loathed Eddie Jones, Borthwick seems like a genuinely likeable fellow who has transformed this team into a group that seems to enjoy playing rugby once more. He seems to have the buy-in and trust of his players and, as a result, in our opinion, needs to be given a fair kick at the can over the next four years. Give him and his team the support, staff, and resources they need, and you could well see England challenging for top honors come Australia, in marked contrast to how they started this World Cup campaign.

England’s roller coaster ride of more lows than highs since that World Cup exit in the Pool stages at their home tournament back in 2015 is now hopefully a thing of the past. Develop some consistency and learn how to play with ball in hand, and England and their supporters could at long last look forward to Saturday afternoons and Test rugby once more.

There is no denying the legacy one of Rugby’s officiating legends, England’s Wayne Barnes, has left on the game – and we’d argue it’s a positive one

While some may not have agreed with some of his decisions in an illustrious 17 year career as a Test referee, Wayne Barnes will go down in history as one of the game’s finest and his legacy will live on long after his final game in the middle which was this year’s World Cup Final

We’ll be the first to ashamedly put our hands up and say that in the early days of Wayne Barnes’ career, he wasn’t our favorite referee. We found him a touch pedantic, slightly stubborn and just a tad irritating. Since then, though, the Englishman has firmly worked his way into our favorites club alongside some of the game’s very best. He’s definitely up there with Wales’ Nigel Owens, South Africa’s Jonathan Kaplan, Ireland’s Alain Rolland, and New Zealand’s Paddy O’Brien to name but a few of the game’s greatest. In short, he has become one of the finest and most likable individuals to wear a whistle round his neck in our beloved game.

While all referees make mistakes, especially in the early days of their careers, Barnes has evolved into one of the best in the business. Sure there have been times where we might have raised a few eyebrows on some of his calls, but certainly in the last ten years, we can honestly say that we never found any of his judgements to be blatantly off the mark.

The fact that in the last few years whenever we’ve seen Barnes’ name pencilled in as the man in charge of a big Test we’ve always breathed a sigh of relief says a lot about the man and the legacy he leaves behind. Was he perfect – no? Was he fair and earned the respect of the players he officiated over – absolutely. Furthermore, we appreciated how he made it a point of communicating with French players in French and even started to get rather handy at Spanish with teams from South America. He made it crystal clear what he expected from the players he refereed in terms of standards, and we also found that he excelled at allowing games to flow and his style suited it. Games he was in charge of tended to have momentum and rarely degenerated into tedious slugfests of endless scrum resets and technicalities. In short, he allowed players and games to breathe.

Consequently we are very sad to see him hang up his whistle for good, and as mentioned in last week’s missive we have shared the collective distaste for any abuse that has been directed at him or his family over the years. Being a referee in rugby is a largely thankless task, but one that Barnes rose to with class, grace, and a touch of panache. While he may no longer be the man in the middle on Saturday afternoons, we are delighted to hear that he will continue to use his legal background to campaign against player and referee abuse in our sport, and hopefully help develop protocols to put an end to the disturbing rise in social media attacks we’ve seen in recent times aimed at officials and players alike.

So we wish “Barnesy” a fond farewell and owe him some heartfelt gratitude for his service to our game over the years, and which we are delighted to hear that he seems set to continue off the pitch. To Wayne Barnes and his family all the very best for the future and we sincerely hope you’ll continue to be the larger than life presence in our game you’ve been for all these years – we are certainly going to miss you!

Well, that’s it for this week, folks. Till our next missive take care and lots to look forward to in the coming months as we start to cast our eyes over the horizon to a Land Down under in four years’ time.

Lineout Calls of the Week – Postcards from France

That Friday, back at the beginning of September, when we all crowded around our TV screens to watch France and New Zealand, kick off Rugby World Cup 2023, now suddenly seems a very long time ago. Since then, a World Cup that was never going to be without its controversies has still somehow managed to deliver one of the most enthralling tournaments since its inception back in 1987.

Many of us, myself and my family included, were lucky enough to be there in person for some of it. The lopsided nature of the draw had its downsides, but nevertheless, in the Quarter Finals in Paris, we were treated to two of the greatest games of rugby we are likely to ever see. There was heartbreak for the host nation France far too early, and despite some of the local interest being somewhat diminished after Les Bleus Quarter Final exit, the Final itself was one for the ages which ultimately saw a team who had perhaps fought for it harder than any other, emerge worthy winners. The Pool stages showcased that despite World Rugby’s best efforts to ensure that the Top Tiers of Rugby remain an exclusive and elite club, rugby is alive and well in many far flung corners of the globe and building a passionate and committed fan base.

In short, it’s been a glorious two months that has brought with it the full range of emotions that such a showpiece event should have. We’ve all cheered, laughed, cried, made new friends, and been wrapped up in a genuine celebration of all the good things about our glorious sport. Despite some distractions, Rugby, for the most part, remains a noble game with its bedrock values of sportsmanship, camaraderie, and respect still very much intact.

In this piece, we’ll look at the things that struck us most about this World Cup and what it means for the future. We’ll be doing a separate piece on what we think the five teams that have emerged atop the World Rankings have learnt from this World Cup, and what they need to do with an eye to the next global showdown in Australia in 2027. However, for now, it’s savoring the fine glass of wine that Rugby World Cup 2023 France has been, which is most important.

So, without any further ado, here’s what struck me most about the last eight weeks, including a memorable two week sojourn in France.

It wasn’t perfect, but France is still a glorious place to host a World Cup

Paris was a fabulous host for the big games and the city’s grandeur lent itself well to the occasion, whilst across the country France’s love of the game was clearly evident, especially in some of its rugby heartlands like Toulouse

France is just a great place to host a Rugby World Cup – that’s all there is to it. Sure, there were some teething problems in the opening weeks of the tournament, but even without France featuring in the final two weekends, the country embraced the tournament hook, line, and sinker. Everywhere you went, you were reminded that France was hosting Rugby’s big show. Although France were knocked out early, and as a result the interest was perhaps not as all encompassing as it could have been, there was still plenty of bonhomie and good cheer towards the supporters of the remaining participating nations who were to be seen everywhere. Some cities such as Toulouse, where we ended our own trip, simply live and breathe rugby – it’s everywhere. Kids were playing rugby in the old town squares, rugby balls were to be seen in every shop window and before long you’d find yourself at the Stade Toulousain shop kitting yourself out in one of their famous jerseys.

People were friendly, enthusiastic, and perhaps best of all even in Paris, you never felt that you were being taken advantage of. Let’s face it there was plenty of opportunity to gouge fans of their hard earned trip of a lifetime cash, but it just never felt like that. Fans at the packed Stade de France for the two Quarter Finals we were at were, for the most part, orderly and respectful. The trains ran well and on time. It was easy to get to and from the games despite the 80,000 plus in attendance at both. The atmosphere was incredible at the Stade de France, and we wouldn’t have missed it for the world.

Our whole experience was perhaps best summed up on our final day in Toulouse, as I took my 11 year old son to the Stade Toulousain shop in the centre of town before catching the train back to Paris and our flight home. Still proudly wearing his French shirt, one of the shop assistants smiled at him as he bought his Toulouse jersey, as his two favorite players, Romain Ntamack and Antoine Dupont, play for the famous French club. “Don’t worry, son,” he said, “we may not have won, but you were here and shared our journey with us – and that is what is important.”

Thank you France!

South Africa’s win showed that sometimes the desire to win can be even more important than the skills needed to do so

South Africa’s three wins in the knockout stages, all by a single point are a feat we are unlikely to ever see again, but as a result they have emerged worthy Champions for a record breaking fourth time

South Africa is the most successful country in World Cup history, having now won the Webb Ellis trophy four times. While they may not have played the most attractive rugby at times, they showed that they simply know better than anyone how to win those fine margins at this level, and what it means to them and their country. Every country deserves to lift a World Cup, but as the tournament progressed, it was very hard not to get behind South Africa regardless of who you supported. South Africans don’t have much to cheer about a lot of the time given the problems their country is grappling with, but it was plain to see how much winning this World Cup meant to them, and especially to do it against their greatest rivals of all time New Zealand.

Their Captain, Siya Kolisi, has been one of the standout players of the tournament. He has embodied the principle of leading from the front and what it means to play for your country. His humility and pride in the jersey has been humbling to watch, as has his remarkable ability to make everyone on the team feel included in South Africa’s remarkable journey this past two months. While this may be his last World Cup in the green and gold, his legacy will serve as an inspiration to not only those in his own country but people around the world for generations to come. In our humble opinion, he is one of the greatest sportsmen of all time, and many could do well to emulate his example, particularly in terms of how to be a leader.

South Africa had perhaps the toughest route to the final of any of the teams. Starting off in the Pool of Death, which saw them lose to Ireland, they had to face the hosts France in the Quarters. That Quarter Final was without doubt one of the most remarkable games of rugby we have ever witnessed, but as they did in all their knockout games, South Africa found a way to control those final ten minutes and secure a one point win, even if all the odds screamed against it. They did the same against England a week later, and then we all know what happened last Saturday against New Zealand. Knockout rugby is a game of very, very fine margins and it’s safe to say that South Africa perhaps more than any other Test nation, know how deep you have to dig to eke out those wins. In between World Cups, that quality may not be very evident in the Springboks, but come the World Cup, they often become a completely different animal.

The World Cup is special for everyone and the pinnacle of any rugby player’s career, but the legacy left by Francois Pienaar and his charges that memorable day back in 1995 in Johannesburg is burned deep into the Springbok psyche, as it continues to unite a nation. Put aside all your technical analysis and stats, and we think you’ll find that it’s that spirit which ends up being the X-factor that brings South Africa home and gives them an edge come World Cups that few other countries can really muster.

Thank you, South Africa, for a remarkable World Cup campaign and sharing your journey in how to unite a nation with us!

Spare a thought for New Zealand and in particular Sam Cane

While we celebrate South Africa’s remarkable win and what it means for their troubled country, one must also take time to honor a New Zealand side that gave it their all and to a man played for each other, even with their Captain sidelined with an unfortunate red card for much of the match

Saturday’s World Cup Final in Paris was a clash between two of International Rugby’s greatest and fiercest rivals. A contest between these two countries is always an awe-inspiring occasion and one of International Sport’s greatest spectacles. Consequently, no quarter is ever given by either side, and Saturday’s encounter saw 46 men throw everything they had into a titanic contest. It may not have been a high scoring affair, but bodies were put on the line and sacrifices made for the full eighty minutes in a pulsating contest that hinged on the finest of margins.

New Zealand are a proud rugby nation, with perhaps the longest and greatest tradition in the sport. Pulling on that black jersey carries exactly the same weight and pride as the Springbok jersey does. Victory elates a nation while defeat breaks 5 million hearts in an instant. The players know the expectation that lies behind the jersey, and failure is a heavy burden to bear.

Spare a thought therefore for New Zealand’s Captain Sam Cane, whose red card reduced his side to 14 men. Put aside the debate around the legitimacy of said card, even though practically everyone agrees that within the letter of the laws as they stand, it was the correct call. Sam Cane has overcome enormous obstacles in his career to get to where he is and potentially lead his side to World Cup glory. He is a decent man and a fine player, and never once have we seen him play in a manner that could jeopardize that character assessment. As a result, having to watch him sidelined on the bench as his country were a man down for much of the match was heartbreaking. It was clear that he felt he had let his team down when they needed him most, and watching him bear such a burden of guilt was hard to take.

To give credit to New Zealand, in his absence, they notched it up another couple of gears and to a man played for their sidelined Captain. They appeared to have the measure of South Africa in the third quarter, and you felt that the engravers would soon be starting to carve the letter N and beyond on the base of the Webb Ellis trophy. However, despite a truly extraordinary effort from New Zealand, it wasn’t to be as the Springboks much vaunted ability to find that extra bit of grunt and resolve to win big games like this once more came to the fore. New Zealand DID not lose that game because of Sam Cane. If anything, in the second half, they became stronger as a result of his predicament. New Zealand were exceptionally worthy finalists who played an outstanding game but lost on the smallest of margins. In short, there is everything to be proud of despite the loss.

Well done, New Zealand. You played some fantastic rugby this World Cup, and you’ll be back stronger as a result!

The abuse piled on referees at times this tournament has NO place in our game – plain and simple!

Although the officiating has come under the microscope at times during this tournament, the abuse levelled at Ben O’Keefe and Wayne Barnes who in our view had excellent World Cups must be stamped out, and a firm line taken for the future as it severely erodes one of the the most basic tenets of our sport – that of respect

Let’s face it, being a Test Rugby referee is probably one of the hardest and most thankless tasks on the planet. Sure there were some big calls this tournament, but for the most part in the crunch matches from the knockout stages onwards we felt that, even allowing for the odd inevitable mistake or borderline decision, the standard of officiating in this tournament has been exceptionally high. As a result, imagine our disappointment at reading of death threats being made against Ben O’Keefe after the France/South Africa final and then Wayne Barnes after the Final between New Zealand and South Africa. Furthermore, numerous officials have been subjected to abuse and put in the crosshairs of social media after certain matches. In short, it is simply unacceptable and must be condemned from the top down and by us as rugby fans.

In the specific cases of both Ben O’Keefe and Wayne Barnes, these are two fine and fair individuals who consistently deliver at the highest level. Are they human? Absolutely, and as a result, they and their team will occasionally miss aspects of the game, which may or may not have had an influence on the ultimate outcome of the match.

As we have repeatedly said, and as echoed by one of the game’s greatest, former Welsh referee Nigel Owens, rugby is an exceptionally fluid, complex, highly technical and dynamic game which requires officials to have not just one but several pairs of eyes in the back of their heads. We share Owens’ concerns that the game has become slightly too technical from a law point of view, and the influence of TMOs could at times be reduced. Some of the technicalities involved not only confuse players and spectators alike, but disrupt the flow of the game and require the officials to have both PhDs in rugby law as well as be able to have a sense of spatial perception that even the most gifted players are incapable of.

Nevertheless, if you look at the two big games that Ben O’Keefe and Wayne Barnes were involved with – the France/South Africa Quarter Final and the New Zealand/South Africa Final, there is unanimous consent that within the letter of the law as it stands now they got the calls right, as hard as it may be for both the losing sides to swallow given there was only one point in both games separating the teams at the final whistle. France lost to South Africa, not because of the officiating but because of some exceptionally poor decision making in the final ten minutes, and New Zealand lost in the Final not because of the red card but because of some uncharacteristically poor goal kicking on their part. Had those kicks gone through New Zealand would have beaten South Africa just as they beat Ireland two weeks earlier by 4 points, even with 14 men.

At the end of the day, teams know that some decisions will go against them, and others will give them a golden, albeit lucky opportunity. It’s how you manage those opportunities and with it the expectations of the officials on any given day that wins you matches. On their own respective days, both France and New Zealand fell just short. We agree that the lawmakers need to take a long hard look at how officiating is carried out, as well as simplify the rule book somewhat after this World Cup, but the derision and threats that O’Keefe and Barnes have received have no place in our sport.

To Barnes and O’Keefe we offer our thanks and respect along with all the other officials and referees who were given an almost impossible task this past two months, but who performed admirably day in day out and in the face of endless criticism and hostility. In short, job well done!

Out with the old as we look ahead to a not so brave new world!

As we cast our thoughts forward to the next World Cup in Australia in 2027, this 4 year cycle should see the back of some old dinosaurs who are stopping the game from embracing the future

So it’s off to Australia in four years’ time, with a bigger tournament and more teams. Eddie Jones failed to deliver Australia’s new dawn in the most spectacular fashion, and Bill Beaumont and World Rugby firmly slammed the door in the face of countries like Portugal, Samoa, Georgia and Uruguay who so inspired us this tournament, at least until 2030. There has been so much to be positive about in this World Cup, but International Rugby is definitely not at the gates of a Brave New World after this World Cup. The upper levels of Rugby’s management remain littered with out of touch dinosaurs in bloated blazers who have little or no interest in how to tap into the potential of rugby in the 21st century. Beaumont’s cozy relationship with the disgraced former President of the French Rugby Federation Bernard Laporte, who is now on trial for fraud, corruption and embezzlement, showed that World Rugby in its present state is nothing more than a cozy cabal of self serving individuals enjoying a rather comfortable ride to their retirement nests.

Bill Beaumont’s term as World Rugby Chairman is up at the end of 2024, and he simply has to go if a legacy for the future can be created in Australia in four years’ time. His main challenger four years ago, Agustin Pichot from Argentina is the only person we’ve seen in World Rugby who has a genuinely exciting and inclusive plan for the future of the sport globally, but his radical thinking was an anathema to the comfortable club that sits at the top of the World Rugby order. Eddie Jones’ departure from the Wallabies was inevitable after this World Cup, but as always, with Jones, it was done in a manner that made it all about him and exemplified his divisive nature. However, much like Beaumont and company, he is a relic of the past and hopefully will start to quickly fade into rugby history. Has his departure from the Wallabies been timed for a run at Beaumont’s replacement? We sincerely hope not.

Thank you to all 20 teams, players and Coaches in this year’s Rugby World Cup, who showed us that despite the staggering level of incompetence and self interest shown by Rugby’s governing bodies both Nationally and Internationally, the love and joy of playing our glorious game is what keeps people coming back for more, and packing the stands to the rafters! They have shown us that Rugby as a global sport is at a crossroads that can only benefit the many rather than the few if the right decisions are made. To the players, coaches, and fans of this Rugby World Cup – we salute you and share your hopes and dreams for the future!!!!